I don't object to it because it's new and likely unnecessary. I shrug at those. But the prominence of the word and brings it to my attention, and after it showed up in a sermon last week I thought harder about what exactly my objection is.
The statement "They are not like us" is not quite the plural of "He is not like us." In the same way "They are not our kind" is not quite a simple plural of "She is not our kind." For someone to be Other in the current sense implies a group membership. The person is not being rejected because they are violent, or rude, or any other personal fault. They are rejected because they are part of some disfavored group. We can see some of the difference by trying to figure out how we might fix this and get them accepted in the two cases. When it is an individual, we could get to know them and find they are not what we thought. That would be extremely unlikely with a whole group. The amount of disproof would have to be large.
Some other choices would be the single "other" changing a specific behavior, or discussing with the observer and one or both changing their minds. Time might reveal that the difference is unimportant. The observer/judge might decide that the person they are angry with is an exception to the stereotype.
But fixing the Othering of a group can only have a group, which is almost always a political solution.
I will point out that those who love to talk about Othering want only political solutions, because that is what they provide. For this, you need us. This is our specialty, talking endlessly with no resolution. It is like the artists who forever want to "start a conversation" because their art doesn't speak for itself but they themselves are very good at art-talk.
It is an exaggeration, but not much of one, to say that those who talk about Othering want to talk about conflict rather than solve it.
