Over a year old now, Beyond Body Count: How many past partners is too many? at N3. Stewart-Williams takes a statistical approach, which is typical for him. The article is interesting in itself (of course), but I was struck by how deftly he disarms a common argument that culture is entirely flexible.
Why are we like this? Why are we so obsessed with other people’s love lives, and why do we make the particular judgments we make?
Many would argue that these things are purely sociological: Our interests and moral convictions are cultivated by the local culture and are ultimately arbitrary conventions, like whether we read from left to right or right to left. Change the culture, the argument goes, and we’d be just as interested in aardvarks or water polo, and we’d make the opposite moral judgments to those we make today.
"...aardvarks or water polo" captures the ridiculousness of that sentiment gloriously. Even the close families of aardvark researchers and water-polo players are not as interested in those topics as with other people's sex lives. Our attention responds to incentives, but it is not infinitely malleable. It is rather like The Gods of the Copy-Book Headings, which reassert themselves year after year, century after century, culture after culture.
