Tuesday, December 18, 2012

Depression Lies


Depression estimates it has gone on much longer than it has, and assures us it will go on indefinitely.

Celebrity Opinions


Syracuse coach Jim Boeheim took advantage of the media attention for his 900th win to give us his views on gun control in view of the recent school shooting. It’s not as if he’s made a particular study of this – that much was clear from his remarks – or has any reason to be trusted as an authority on any subject other than coaching basketball.  I understand that if people give you the opportunity to express your favorite opinion to a wide audience, it is likely hard to turn away.  But how does one not have the sense of perspective to realise you are rather a fraud to be offering an opinion at all?

It is similar to Christian athletes and Grammy winners taking the opportunity to give all the praise and glory to My Lord Jesus.  That’s terrible theology unless one bends the meanings of words significantly, but at least in that situation, they are not just giving their opinion about God in general, but as it specifically relates to their work and success. Had Boeheim blathered on evangelising about some remarkable meditation technique that allowed him to focus better on the task at hand, that would at least relate to his expertise and the moment.

We listen to them because we like famous people and think they must know something we don’t. Even more, we believe that success in one area has some spillover effect that people understand a lot of other stuff, too.  I recall an irate comment during Iran-Contra in the 80’s to the effect that “Who would you rather have leading you into battle, Oliver North or Ted Kennedy?”  That’s pretty clearly going to go in Ollie’s favor, but it’s not the right question.  I trust North to lead troops more than I trust my dentist, too, but that doesn’t mean I want the colonel working on my teeth.

They believe they are worth listening to for different reasons.  They have succeeded at fairly arbitrary, largely symbolic endeavors.  Double the size of a basketball court or halve the size of the ball and over time, different players and coaches succeed at it.  There would be some overlap, because athletic and management skills have some transfer.  But in all likelihood, Coach Boeheim is in a different profession, managing different people with less dramatic success and some other guy is getting 900 wins.  There are general skills of music or acting, but styles and trends have enormous variability – change the game and different bands and actresses become famous.

Therefore, they are used to inhabiting spaces of symbolic importance for somewhat arbitrary reasons.  They are six-foot people operating sixty-foot animatronic figues already.  What’s a few more feet?

.
This is a good spot to check over at ESPN and see what Rick Reilly has been writing, seeing that he now fancies himself an expert on social events.  Ah, a football player has lost two teammates to suicide, and wants answers why.  Yeah, that’s going to be illuminating.  Young quarterback intermittently thinking about other young men’s depression, sportswriter explaining that to us

Monday, December 17, 2012

Tinfoil Hats


Terri laughingly mentioned tinfoil hats, which reminded me of a bit of mental health knowledge you might find useful someday.  I knew some guys who lined their hats with foil, years ago.  It comes from the belief that someone was trying to broadcast radio waves into their heads, so they would line their hats as some protection.

They heard voices, and the mind seeks explanation – cannot rest until it has an explanation, in fact.  We are an explaining species.  We don’t tolerate things that just happen for no apparent reason.  These days, it’s not radio waves, it’s implanted chips.  Before that, it was electronic signals from computers, and before that, from satellites.  Who is doing the tormenting also varies with the times.  Family members are always good nominees of course, but Russians, the CIA, the Mafia, the military, or obscurer organizations have all had their days of popularity – precisely when they were popular in the culture at large.

When I was young there was still the cartoon trope of delusional people who thought they were Napoleon.  The French were among the first to observe the mentally ill closely, especially in the early 19th C.  See Marat-Sade, for example. Thinking one was Napoleon, in that context, likely referred to grandiosity – what we once called manic and now more precisely call BPAD  No one thinks they are Napoleon these days. He’s long dead and French – where’s the grandness of that?

As with regular folk scrambling for solutions when tragedy occurs, the mentally ill latch on to whatever raw material is around them for their explanations.  Theirs are just more obviously inaccurate.

One Perspective


It will be hard not to sound unsympathetic with this, but I think I have sorrow covered.  A piece of the sun has forever gone out of the sky for some families in Connecticut.  However well they may get on with their lives, they will never fully get past the tragedy.  They will have pain forever.  Intermittently perhaps, because the brain itself cannot sustain any emotion indefinitely.  But the abyss will always be nearby.  I know some who had such tragedy years, even decades ago, who still have pain from it.  I had an aunt who lost her first child to SIDS over Christmas in 1951, and her husband on Christmas in 1981.  The president did not come speak to her.

Yet in fact, there are lots of them.  As with a plane crash, we see this event as some superspecial tragedy because it involves many people.  But this is not a greater tragedy because it has a 27 in front of it.  It is 27 individual terrible tragedies, much like the many individual tragedies that happen every day, one at a time.  The dramatic events make a better story, so we remember them better.  We sort of (gulp) like these tragedies, because then we can apply our favorite explanations to them, confirming our world view. Like, or enjoy are not quite the right words – but something like that.  We are excited by such things.

I see this all the time.  I know a few dozen young men who describe like this one.  I met a new one today.  I know a few dozen mothers who lost schoolchildren. This happens in miniature every day, but the national imagination is not captured, so we cross the street and pass by.  I am not impressed by our national outpourings of emotion.  We are having real feelings, but we are having real feelings about something else.  These events activate other stuff.  Which is why people leap to conclusions and want to inject their political views about guns or their social views about mental health. Or school security. Or school prayer.  

When the events fit some American narrative, I suppose there is a reason for the country to get exercised.  If the victims were chosen for their race or their beliefs, then something central to American definition is at stake.  But random violence is just the evil that has been with us since the dawn of time, the natural overflow of a fallen race.

Hey, I’d love it if you sent us more money over here at public mental health.  But how many false positives are you going to lock up, or follow around all the time?  Ten times the number, with ten times the cost, and ten times the loss of freedom?

Worried about the guns?  It’s already illegal. Please, worry about the mentally ill with driver’s licenses instead, because there’s more death there. They are among our most vulnerable citizens and often live in our worst neighborhoods, but we take away their ability to protect themselves with firearms because of the increased risk.  That may be the correct calculation, but there is a cost to them.  So too with the greater danger, driving. Or over-the-counter medication.  Or alcohol. We could tighten up on all those things, too, if you like.  After all, prohibition worked so well last time, why not try it on guns and aspirin, too? 

You want bad things to stop happening, and the way you think they will stop happening is if people will only listen to what you have been saying for years.  I mean, it’s just obvious, right?  It’s good for lumbago and sciatica, apoplexy and epilepsy, tired blood and the diminution of the marital impulse.

I should not be so harsh.  We are primitive creatures, huddled together against the night, and if we act like the rabbits listening to Captain Holly on Watership Down, it may just be the only way we can get through.  We may need periodic horror to identify with, to express loudly what we call senseless tragedy, as an expression of who we are and what is important to us.

Sunday, December 16, 2012

Me 'n IQ

I'm not entirely sure what I thought about IQ prior to the mid-80's.  I am aware what surprised me as I learned more, but that is only a clue to previous beliefs.  I doubt that my historical opinions matter much at this point, unless they shed light on the change, so I will try and keep it short.

There is a belief that IQ is largely a cultural construct, not a true indicator of anything of much value - every environment requires different skills and what we call intelligence is just what works for the dominant class in the West; there is also a belief that IQ tests measure a factor g, for "general intelligence," that holds up cross-culturally as an indicator of something that really corresponds to being smart.  That is, if you test people in Albania, Afghanistan, and Algeria, then ask a sampling of villagers who the smartest people are in the group, there will be a good correspondence.

I thought something between the two. But mostly, I thought it was about individuals.  What your individual number was had some importance.  It didn't say anything about your musical abilities or writing or humor or emotional balance, but it gave a vague indication that you might pick things up quickly.  It was sort of a glorified knack for crossword puzzles, or bridge, or trivial pursuit. For lots of stuff, but not everything.  I think I had read about Jensen's research, and people shouting him down on campuses, refusing to let him speak because he claimed there were racial differences in IQ.  I had heard that he was not a typical racist, because he believed that orientals were at the top of the pecking order.  I noted the irony, but figured it was all a tempest in a teapot, because a few points here or there don't make much difference in an individual.

Which they don't.  You cannot differentiate a ten-point IQ difference all that accurately, except among people you know pretty darn well.  20 points is consistently noticeable, but even there you'll make mistakes.  Too many other factors get in the way, because they also have real effects on abilities and personality.  Determination, charm, expressiveness, discipline - in any given individual, any of these may have been more important than candlepower in determining their life outcome. Ten points of IQ is like being one inch taller.  You might be a better athlete, or better looking, or more confident because of it, but not enormously.  Certainly no guarantee.

I used to get Games magazine, and as I expected, there were types of puzzles I excelled at, and other types I never quite caught on to. Tracy and I would compete in road rallies with another couple and do quite well. I began to wonder if I might be more than good, but very good, at certain mental pursuits.  I saw the Mega test in Omni, did quite well, started corresponding with Ron Hoeflin, and eventually joined a couple of the upper-level IQ societies.  After a few years, I did not renew membership.  I have stories, but I'm not sure too many folks would be interested.

I did, however, begin to learn some real information about IQ - the things that weren't rumor or opinion, but had some research base.  Those are subject to bias and interpretation, same as anything else, but at least it's something.  More and more, it became clear that the common beliefs in the social sciences were based on very little. Stephen Jay Gould's Mismeasurement of Man was pretty easily disassembled by anyone with even a little knowledge, yet it remained a sacred text.  Scanning the membership lists, I once noted - it was a small, closed, group after all - that there were a preponderance of NW Europeans and Jews, and greatly outnumbered women.  I thought that was still at least mostly cultural, and my observation would lead to interesting speculations and discussions about male competitiveness, or didactics, or expectations, or whatever.

One person did write to me privately to say "The Asians are coming.  We're not seeing it because it's still an English-based test.  Not long now." I became aware that IQ really wasn't much use in predicting individual accomplishments.  But it was a good predictor of group accomplishments, because over a large sample, things like attractiveness, grit, luck, and attitude even out.  It was any group, not just racial.  If you took a pile of 100 people with IQ 85 and 100 people with IQ 95, you were going to find more problems in the first group.  More jail time, more illegitimate children, poorer grades, more drug use.  There would be a wide variation within each group.  Some of the 85's would do just fine and some to the 95's had ruined their lives.  But the trend was clear.

For the rest, the response was varied, from "No, that can't be true.  It must be accidental, or temporary" to "Yeah, that's pretty much what Jensen found.  Be careful where you mention that."  There was no discussion.  So I went back and read Jensen, and a few other more daring researchers, and found what the problem is.  The racial difference was more than a few points.  It was a lot. And the traditional arguments put forward that the tests were biased, or wrong, or measured something else, could sustain examination.

This seemed odd to me, and didn't square with my own experience.  Yet my experience was from two pools, neither of which is large enough to be a Jeopardy! category:  William and Mary students, and Black People From New Hampshire.  Not for many years did I notice that neither were a representative sample.  I figured it the gap would close.  I figured it was a late-blooming civil rights thing.  I put it lower in my lists of things to ponder.

I don't know how it came back in my mind.  Reading Charles Murray, likely. But almost my first re-experience of the subject was learning that The Gap has not closed.  Despite educational experiments galore, all of which promise to bring under-represented black students up to the same accomplishments, the numbers have not budged.  It's still one standard deviation.  So holding up prejudice and expectations as the main cause is pretty much gone, now; however bad we say prejudice still is, it was clearly worse 50 years ago, yet the scores are the same.

This is a huge problem, for which I have no solution.  The pool of people under 85 IQ, which we are going to have a harder and harder time finding jobs for, and who already contribute way more than their share of pathology, is still largely white, though disproportionally black, hispanic, and native. But they are falling behind in a complex society, and things will likely get worse.

Here are the two wincing take-aways.  It means that affirmative action problems help the people who need it least, leaving those who need it most untouched. It also means that the nationalistic solution would be to limit immigration, to preserve what jobs we can for people who are already citizens.  Yet I don't know that nationalistic and Christian solutions are the same here.

Isaiah's Job

Isaiah's Job was linked in a comment section, about prophesying to the masses versus the remnant. It was written for The Atlantic by Albert Jay Nock in 1936.

It's not quite true, or at any rate, I disagree with much of it.  I don't have so much contempt for the masses as Nock, and I don't think intellect is quite so much a key.  It is all rather elitist in tone.  Yet I think it might be better than half-true, an encouragement for some who are weary, and a message not heard so very often.

It is at a minimum interesting.

Political and Social Versus Spiritual

We sometimes think of the long-term consequences of something as a substitute for thinking of the eternal consequences.  I look at political and social trends and have dire thoughts about where things are headed, and the deterioration of character that occurs when people give up religion, but still feel the need to be self-righteous.  I grow angry.

But from an eternal perspective, I have pity instead. People no longer have religion, but they always have a metaphysic, however they deny or hide.  So of course they are self-righteous, and it is not an evil, but clinging to the last remnants of goodness that they know.  They are eating the husks because they must eat something.  They are sheep without a shepherd.

Saturday, December 15, 2012

Post 3900 - Right To Work

There's a quote by MLK circulating, putting forward the idea that he thought "right to work" laws were a fraud and a hindrance to civil rights.  It just says "1961" for attribution, and I can't find it anywhere until it shows up a few days ago.  I suspect it is made up, or is at minimum a misquote.  It is altogether too neat and too perfect.  But I have been wrong in such guesses before.  Does anyone know if the quote is sourced?

Impulsive Solutions

Crap.  I had a post that kicks someone deservedly, but might hurt another reader.

She deserves it, too, but she's a nice person who has done me no harm and some good, so even if her idea is contemptible I don't want to hurt her.

So just take my word for it - I knocked it outa the park.

Friday, December 14, 2012

Walkin' In Memphis

One of my all-time favorite songs

Fashionable Politics - The Long Wave

This is where I wanted to go with this topic from the start.

Through the mid-60's, becoming a mainstream American was the fashion.  In none of the civil rights rhetoric from Reconstruction to Selma was there the least blather about diversity being our strength.  MLK's speeches hew close to the theme of the black man being counted in the mainstream, of coming into the mainstream, of being deserving and eligible of being in the mainstream.

Neither was there much celebration of differences among other ethnic groups.  Every group had its customs, and it was considered acceptable to cherish those.  But it was also considered acceptable to abandon them completely, and rejoice solely in having "made it," being accepted as real Americans. Greeks, Irish, Hispanics - we tended to call those "Latins" in those days - measured their progress by mainstream acceptance.

While there were some voices early on in feminist writing suggesting a restructuring of roles and society entirely, most of the early emphasis was on "women are as good as men, the same as men, should be treated the same as men, etc." WASP culture was not despised, it was envied, admired, and imitated.  It was the fashion.

That is no longer the case.  To be different from the mainstream - not hugely, but distinguishably - is now the fashion.  I don't say that one fashion is better than the other.  the change worked against Mr. Romney and for Mr. Obama in the last election, which I regret, but I don't see that either fashion is better. (There is some exception to this, which I may get to.  But indifference is my starting point.)  I don't say it's worse that difference is now the fashion, but I note that this is so. We used to brag about being a melting pot.  Now we prefer to say we are a mosaic. The religious drive in the 1960's was to be "ecumenical."

Offer whatever theories you like about how this occurred: the changes in immigration policy in the 1920's and the 1960's; the purely visually imaginative difficulty of incorporating black faces as representative, which had not been so hard with Slavs, Jews, Swedes; the shattering of the idea of unity during the Protestant Reformation, or the discrediting of ideas of unity by the National Socialists; increased worldwide communication or travel; communist propaganda to divide Americans; watching TV; drugs and novelty-seeking; Tolkien and Lewis lauding the diversity of fictional other sentient creatures.  Whatever.  It is enough to notice that the previous ideal is now an object of scorn.  Everything from "My Big Fat Greek Wedding" to performance art does not merely exalt the hipness of rebellion, but the contemptibleness of being "whitebread," boring, married, straight, 9-to-5, parents.  Much better to be "quirky," eh? And it has long been a cliche to note that the art community values what is "transgressive."

Is this some revenge factor, or a sour-grapes response from individuals who couldn't cut it, and projected their own rebellion onto their group? Is it just the natural flow of trendiness?  Dunno.

In evolution, both values much be present for survival, of course, and they have always been held in tension.  One must be conformist enough to remain in the tribe, but different enough to attract a mate.  These themes have likely played out in every century, and we are merely seeing one aspect at present.  We did celebrate differences even in the bad old days, and plenty of people still aspire to the mainstream now, caring not a fig for diversity.  Or they aspire to a new, different mainstream, just as conformist as the old one but with a beat the kids can dance to.  Though there is reason to think this may be a bit new.  America is far more a mixed society than any previous one.  That's not easy, and perhaps embracing a new extreme of celebrating diversity is the only way of getting along, even if a lot of it is strained and mere formality.

I make no prediction where this is going, nor what outcomes are to be preferred.  I have ideas, but I haven't really played them out in the imagination fifty years or so.

Thursday, December 13, 2012

Me 'n IQ

I don't think even my sons know how radical was the change in my thinking during the 1980's.  They were children and not much aware of the issue, and by the time it became something they could understand, I was in an entirely different position on the subject.

Aside from the human-interest factor of how a mind changes, I may also have something worth pointing out here.  I still have to finish up that political fashion thing, however.  I'm not especially organised in the middle of writing the annual Christmas letter every year, and this one's no exception.

Fashionable Politcs - Overstating

I wondered when imagining arguments against my premise whether some would find the word "fashion" unnecessarily belittling.  Whether one thinks that it's 5% or 10% of the electorate that votes one way because of bandwagon effect, or thinking it's more stylish, that's still more than a bit demeaning to the others, who base their vote on more substantive data, isn't it?  Even if it's a continuum, why go out my way to accentuate the negative?

Because neurology teaches us that it's not 5 or 10% of us that vote that way, it's 100% of us.  That is, all of us are affected by what we see as our group's fashions, and this forms at least part of our values.  We would like to be logical creatures, but this is only partly true.

So, does this leave us all on an even footing then?  No, it does not.  One never sees the remotest suggestion in liberal writing that they can apply this question to themselves, even if they know the general principle.  It's what makes Jonathan Haidt so unusual and worth reading.  He has popped onto the scene and said "Okay, we know this applies to conservatives.  And in theory, we know that this applies to everyone.  Therefore...could it be...nah, but...yes, that would have to imply that this applies to us as well!"  You just never find this, never the slightest self-doubt.*

Not that conservatives or libertarians ever ante up to that card game all that often, but at least there are some, usually religious writers.  It is on those few that I pin my hopes that future generations might someday see clearly what happened here (cue last speech from "Camelot").

*There is an imitation that provides immunity to self-observation, and it particularly infuriates me because of my own history.  There are liberals who in all humility acknowledge shortcomings - but they only acknowledge the type of shortcomings they think conservatives have, and cop to lesser versions of it.  "Yes, I find a resistance to seeing white privilege in my own life.  I have to fight against it."  Or "We all are too materialistic here in America, and I'm guilty of that, too."  You see the trick?  It is arrogance squared, disguised (even from oneself) as humility. Christians are especially susceptible to this, likely because they have some conscience reminding them that they should be humble.  It's a very Screwtape situation.  Or perhaps God In The Dock, "The Dangers of National Repentance." I see AVI-commenter David Foster commented on this very thing over at Chicago Boyz 30 months ago.

Update:  I just thought of a conservative Christian who does this in reverse, and I'm pretty ticked at her as well.  So it's not an entirely liberal phenomenon.

Fashionable Politics - Anecdotes

I have three long posts backed up.  It occurs to me, editing them, that I am not saying anything that others aren't.  I am just trying my hand at saying things well, to see if I have anything to add.  But I don't think I do.  So I will try a different tack. No close arguments here.  My brain is too feeble.

BTW, the number of people saying "a different tact" makes me crazy.  The phrase comes from sailing, and tacking into the wind.

The oldest incomplete post is the followup on fashionable politics.  This brilliant salon was not a lot of help, frankly. However, as I myself have not been scintillating, I can hardly grouse more than a little at you.  So.  Anecdotes, to set the stage.

A psychiatrist friend had traveled with her new husband through Tennessee.  There was a conference of some sort there, and they thought it a good excuse to get away for a bit.  She is an excellent storyteller and conversationalist, and upon her return she was playing up the cultural differences - not to the advantage of the Tennesseans, as you may imagine.  She mentioned in particular that not only were young men driving pickup trucks with flag decals and suggestive bumper stickers, but young women too.  Also, she noticed that there was much more variety of supermarket checkout "news"-papers and scandal sheets.  A few sentences later, she smirked, "yeah it's a pretty red state." 

I smirked back, because even though Lisa is quite liberal, she is able to hear and more objective than most folks. "Well, Tennessee is pretty purple, actually.  And you're sure it's Republican women buying the Enquirer?"  I did not mention that mention that Democrats have carried the less-than-high-school-education demographic as far back as we've been measuring that. And now I would have an even readier answer, because Obama carrying the single women, with or without children, was big news this election.  Who does she think is buying the Star, and what does she think the marital status of suggestive bumper stickers is?  Hell, I don't know that they are Democrats, either, but that would sure be the way to bet, wouldn't it?  With the Dems owning both groups, you'd think they'd be strong in the overlap.

Next, my cousin visited NH from the Pacific Northwest in the summer of 2000.  He has been here occasionally over the years, but not much as an adult. Basically, what he knows is what he reads in the mainstream media.  Driving up from Logan to Wolfeboro, he had noticed some bookstores visible from the highway in Massachusetts, but not any in NH.  "Hell no!  This is Bush country here!." I will note in passing that the Exeter-Hampton-Portsmouth area he saw first has an extremely high concentration of great little used-book stores, and the rest of his route up Rte 16 and over has a few as well.  Maybe he only notices Barnes and Nobles or Borders or something.  But either way, his cultural assumption was striking - especially as it is exactly backward. 

Third, my hospital has groups of students in all the time, most notably nursing students and medical students.  Both are predominantly female.  It is clear that the Dartmouth medical students, who are a bit older and likely a bit brighter, do not mingle much with the nursing students, even though they share space.  No one says a negative word, but to an outside observer it is obvious that they consider themselves above them.  And from their perspective, they are.  They are not likely to share space socially for the rest of their days.  The nursing students giggle more, and are a bit coarser.  They don't know how that pushes them down socially, but the med students know it.

But to a man in his late fifties, their conversation sounds equally shallow and devoted to establishing and upholding fashion norms for their tribe.  Eye-rolling and other nonverbals figure prominently.  It's just a different fashion. Sometimes it is explicit anti-fashion, about those women who are too deep in downmarket popular culture, including a classmate or two who should smarten up and get her act together. 

That's not a Republican or Democrat example, BTW.  For all I know, those med students might all be Republicans and the nurses Democrats.  I'm just noticing class assumptions here.

HPYS women and their imitators hear "single women" as a demographic and think of themselves.  Everyone slips into that bad habit.  But I think liberals are especially oblivious in this area.  They really don't get that this popular culture that they think themselves above and go to great lengths to separate themselves from, does not all belong to their political opponents.  In fact, it looks more likely that if they vote at all, they would lean "D."

Wednesday, December 12, 2012

Hall Of 100

ESPN's Hall Of 100 is so insanely wrong that there is no point in even criticising the choices in a list.  I'll just touch on it.

They don't understand that hitter's eras and pitcher's eras skew statistics so ridiculously that the players in those years have to be considered first in their context.  Batting .300 in the 1930's was an average accomplishment.  Batting .300 in the 1960's was superb. Mel me no Otts, please. Al me no Simmons.  Lefty Grove is the #47th best, really?  I might pick him first.

They don't understand that leadoff hitters are significantly less valuable than number 3 or 4 hitters.  Pete Rose does not only belong at #37, he doesn't belong at #87,

They don't understand that fielding is only 15% of the game.  Great fielding is nice.  That's all.  Relatedly, they don't understand that someone has to play catcher, and that is the most valuable position in the field.

Monday, December 10, 2012

Wargaming

A friend had a WWII strategy game, long in the making, come out this fall.  The War: Europe 1939-1945, put out by Compass Games, finally started shipping last month. I have only a passing familiarity with this type of extended table game, pioneered decades ago by Avalon Hill, but I expect this to be seriously good.  I knew Ernie as a history fanatic and early wargamer at William and Mary, and among his many other fascinating careers, he teaches at a local college (local to him, over in Maine that is). WWII, Europe has long been his favorite era.  He is the person that put me on to both Joel Garreau's Nine Nations and David Hackett Fischer's Albion's Seed as they came out, both on my short list of essential reading. He absolutely knows his stuff.

These are the complex and precise games that attract serious students of military history - the cost would certainly daunt the merely curious, but is standard for the genre.  Some effort has been made to make it accessible to new gamers with solitaire and some scenarios that can be played more quickly.  But it's the real deal otherwise, with expected games of 50 hours.

If this is new to you, you need to know something of what to expect in this type of gaming.  What you can do within the game must be something which could plausibly have occurred.  To take Copley's example, one cannot posit "What if the Japanese had had an atomic bomb prior to the war?"  (I believe the proper response to that is "Yeah well, what if the Belgians had had a magnetic Death Ray?  What about that?") But trying on how things would have been different if Stalin hadn't killed so many of his generals during the purges is fair game.

We see this echoed in literary forms redoing history.  There is speculative fiction in which even wild possibilities are allowed, steampunk tends strongly to this; then there is the time travel genre, certainly the most common in visual media, in which the plot is confined to the otherwise possible, save that a single wildcard group or individual can act with foreknowledge; then there is counterfactual history, which is more constrained still, in which the author tries to describe what most plausibly would result from a small, realistic change at the outset of some historical event.  These are often most attractive in situations that appear in retrospect to have hinged on some small event anyway:  what if air reconnaissance had focused more on the northern attack routes at Pearl Harbor; what if the British had pursued at the Battle of Jutland; what if Jeb Stuart had "done his duty" and the Confederate States succeeded at secession.  All are a type of alt history - wargaming is most like the last of these, though there is overlap and the categories are not clean.