Saturday, November 21, 2026

Good Thinking Leads to Good Writing

Over a year old now, Beyond Body Count:  How many past partners is too many? at N3. Stewart-Williams takes a statistical approach, which is typical for him.  The article is interesting in itself (of course), but I was struck by how deftly he disarms a common argument that culture is entirely flexible.

Why are we like this? Why are we so obsessed with other people’s love lives, and why do we make the particular judgments we make?

Many would argue that these things are purely sociological: Our interests and moral convictions are cultivated by the local culture and are ultimately arbitrary conventions, like whether we read from left to right or right to left. Change the culture, the argument goes, and we’d be just as interested in aardvarks or water polo, and we’d make the opposite moral judgments to those we make today.

"...aardvarks or water polo" captures the ridiculousness of that sentiment gloriously. Even the close families of aardvark researchers and water-polo players are not as interested in those topics as with other people's sex lives. Our attention responds to incentives, but it is not infinitely malleable. It is rather like The Gods of the Copy-Book Headings, which reassert themselves year after year, century after century, culture after culture.

Thursday, November 19, 2026

Doomsday Prepper

 I used to be a doomsday prepper.  I regret all of it. 

He's right to pay attention to the disasters that are common to your area. Up here it is power outages due to ice storms. Be good and ready for that.  The problem is once we start thinking along those lines, it doesn't stop.

 Anyway, I own all that crap. Actually, I own multiple versions of all of it, from the low-end Temu-style picks to the more expensive items (what I call the Gucci options). They all just sit in some pack or closet somewhere.

You may assume that, with things as grim as they are out there, I would feel vindicated. I don’t. I regret all of it. God, what a waste. I get sick thinking about it.

Things Too Good To Be True

 ...are usually to good to be true.  The Trouble With Serendipity at Works in Progress. 

 Pasteur was probably the best-paid scientist in France at the time, and sold his inventions commercially. His secrecy might have been rational: patents weren’t allowed on medicines in France then, so keeping the method secret would have helped him maintain his monopoly on producing them. Pasteur was so cagey that he didn’t allow his collaborators to take notes, took his notebooks with him when he traveled, and published his methods (without much detail) only months after announcing his discoveries.

Slavery in the Bible

 Earl passes along an essay by Martin Turner explaining slavery in the Bible.

The Old Testament does not have a word for our concept of ‘slave’. We do not have a word for a particular Old Testament concept. There is a word which is contextually translated ‘slave’, but it means just a ‘worker’ or a subordinate. This word is ‘ebed’. There is no English word which can be used to translate ‘ebed’ consistently and idiomatically. 

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Jack and Diane

I am not going to link to it. But it's not just the coarseness of the lyrics, it's the incredible arrogance of his tone of voice that make this the most obnoxious pop song ever. So of course it is still being played as background.

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Channeling Jimi Hendrix

It's the second half that was legendary.


 

Monday, November 16, 2026

Late Bronze Age Collapse

For those of us who are fascinated by the mysterious Late Bronze Age Collapse, as described in 1177 BC, The Year Civilisation Collapsed by Eric Cline, there is  now a scented candle you can buy commemorating it.  The scent is burning cedar, which makes good historical sense. "I love the smell of burning cedar in the morning."

My own view on the mystery is that an expansion of one of the Steppe peoples created pressure on multiple tribes in the Mediterranean, who joined the armies - and navies - of various plundering tribes who attacked by sea the wealthier areas such as Egypt. 

Thanks to ACX for the link. 

Is the Optimal Rate of Charitable Giving $0?

Well, this will put the cat among the pigeons, or should, when a Lutheran missionary who is also a statistician makes the argument that the optimal rate of charitable giving might be near zero.  Lyman Stone goes after what he thinks would be the strongest claim of Effective Altruism, that giving to effective causes, is actually* bad.  What Is The Optimal Rate of Charitable Giving?

3) Moreover, and at a more general level, the objective of charity should probably not be to “save the largest number of lives from a fixed budget,” but, rather, “to alter society in such a way that people no longer require charity.” Saving a life only to have to save it again tomorrow is, arguably, not saving a life at all. 

The heart of his argument is that with rising GDP people solve their own problems.  This gets us out of the trap that sending food undermines a nation's farmers and fishermen.  In fact anything we just give them undermines the people trying to make a living in that sector. Job training would theoretically be good, but has a history of teaching people to do things they don't need but are now convinced are the key to success.

It reminds me of Gregory Clark's A Farewell to Alms , though emphasizing institutional changes rather than inherited cultural abilities. I will note that I have read some bits of criticism of Clark that are fair, but most of the controversy around him is in the form of "That can't be true. It denies or leaves out lots of things we just know have to be true about development, and besides, it would be ugly." I expect Stone will face the same.  But as with Clark, I do look forward to reviews that see beyond fashion and signalling.

So. Does this change how we give? 

*Statisticians like the word "actually" a lot. 

That Word "Othering"

I don't object to it because it's new and likely unnecessary. I shrug at those. But the prominence of the word brings it to my attention, and after it showed up in a sermon last week I thought harder about what exactly my objection is.

The statement "They are not like us" is not quite the plural of "He is not like us." In the same way "They are not our kind" is not quite a simple plural of "She is not our kind." For someone to be Other in the current sense implies a group membership. The person is not being rejected because they are violent, or rude, or any other personal fault. They are rejected because they are part of some disfavored group. We can see some of the difference by trying to figure out how we might fix this and get them accepted in each case. When it is an individual, we could get to know them and find they are not what we thought. That would be extremely unlikely with a whole group.  The amount of disproof would have to be large. 

Some other choices would be the single "other" changing a specific behavior, or discussing with the observer and one or both changing their minds. Time might reveal that the difference is unimportant. The observer/judge might decide that the person they are angry with is an exception to the stereotype. 

But fixing the Othering of a group can only have a group solution, which is almost always a political solution. 

I will point out that those who love to talk about Othering want only political solutions, because that is what they provide. For this, you need us.  This is our specialty, talking endlessly with no resolution. It is like the artists who forever want to "start a conversation" because their art doesn't speak for itself but they themselves are very good at art-talk.

It is an exaggeration, but not much of one, to say that those who talk about Othering want to talk about conflict rather than solve it.  

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Substack Post

I have a new Substack post about Sexual Assault on men. It doesn't seem to fit this audience, but it's there if you want to read it.

Navy Hymn

Men's Chorus did this last week for Veteran's Day. This isn't us, but this is the arrangement we sang, except we did not do the airmen's verse or the Amen.


 

 

The Historian and the Husband

 Earl has a post up about changes in science versus changes in religion The Historian and the Husband. 

It seems like something in Chesterton and Lewis, but I think that was more about belief in a woman's faithfulness. This has a humorous example instead. Humorous unless you are the husband, that is.

I would add that new discoveries in science are usual, while most questions in a religion have been asked by someone and answered to general satisfaction, often many times before. We don't go back to Aristotle and Plato in philosophy because we like them, but because we think they asked the right questions. A lot of people have gone over their territory. So also Augustine, Aquinas and others with more disagreement around them, such as Luther, Calvin, or Joseph Smith.  Sometimes new archaeological or historical information comes in, or general belief changes around something like evolution, setting off new(ish) questions, but those happen less often.

Saturday, November 14, 2026

Power Argues With Power

And it should. We don't want powers getting along with each other.  The Founding Fathers creted a systm that required a majority rather than a coalition government for wise reasons. In Our Republic, Power Argues With Power, 

By contrast, consensus systems run on deals. Every group gets its piece: a subsidy, a spending, a regulation. Add them together, and you’ve got a system crippled by bureacracy and spending, and nobody can punish the total of it because nobody designed for the total of it.

That’s the EU in a nutshell. (It’s also what the modern Senate filibuster does. By removing the traditional filibuster mechanism of holding the floor and actually arguing, almost everything has to be bargained. And so we get those awful omnibus bills.)  

Recent Links

James had serious questions about the possible HSV-1 influence on IQ, that I linked from Aporia last week. A guest-poster at Cremieux has already jumped in with reasoning that supports James's immediate suspicions. Did Herpes Cause the Achievement Gap?

A different IQ discussion at Aporia, about Afro-Carribeans vs Indo-Carribeans in Trinidad and Tobago. 

Immigrants are almost twice as likely to start a business as their native-born peers.  Absolutely bears out in my sons and daughters-in law. Two of my Americans plus their wives have side-hustles in photography, one now dormant. The latest potential DIL (American) is trying to establish an online presence in teaching calm and wisdom - but has a regular marketing job. But the Romanians both have major side hustles, and the Filipina has the largest of all, even though they all have regular jobs.  None have done this with any kind of government loan or support for immigrants. Neither my wife nor I were ever side-hustle people, though we flirted with that at times.

Gregory Clark and the inheritance Social Status again, this time at City Journal. The association between first-degree relatives is modest, suggesting environment still has a say. But the decay of status to second, third, fourth-degree relatives is surprisingly small, suggesting that it's genes plus luck, not environment.

Clark, instead, looks at what happens as you move further out on the family tree. When one moves from siblings all the way to cousins in that same housing-value analysis, the correlation drops only modestly, to 0.21. The general rule he discovers—across many different status measures, and across several centuries notwithstanding massive changes to society and technology—is that these correlations, despite starting out at a modest level, drop by only about one-fifth with each extra degree of relatedness. (Cousins are two steps more distant than siblings in this sense.

Thus, our focus shouldn’t linger on the modest correlations among immediate family members. Those aren’t a beautiful testament to the randomness of life and the possibility of change; they’re just misleading. Rather, the very slow decay of the correlations as we move through family trees is where the action is. It reveals a “latent” status that is extremely persistent. Clark finds measurable links in status even among fourth cousins, whose shared ancestors are five generations back. 

 Seven Dudes Could Take Over Any Small Town in America  No, not at gunpoint. Just move there. An interesting counterintuitive idea that some of us have experience with.