Well, this will put the cat among the pigeons, or should, when a Lutheran missionary who is also a statistician makes the argument that the optimal rate of charitable giving might be near zero. Lyman Stone goes after what he thinks would be the strongest claim of Effective Altruism, giving to effective causes, is actually* bad. What Is The Optimal Rate of Charitable Giving?
3) Moreover, and at a more general level, the objective of charity should probably not be to “save the largest number of lives from a fixed budget,” but, rather, “to alter society in such a way that people no longer require charity.” Saving a life only to have to save it again tomorrow is, arguably, not saving a life at all.
The heart of his argument is that with rising GDP people solve their own problems. This gets us out of the trap that sending food undermines a nation's farmers and fishermen. In fact anything we just give them undermines the people trying to make a living in that sector. Job training would theoretically be good, but has a history of teaching people to do things they don't need but are now convinced are the key to success.
It reminds me of Gregory Clark's A Farewell to Alms , though emphasizing institutional changes rather than inherited cultural abilities. I will note that I have read some bits of criticism of Clark that are fair, but most of the controversy around him is in the form of "That can't be true. It denies or leaves out lots of things we just know have to be true about development, and besides, it would be ugly." I expect Stone will face the same. But as with Clark, I do look forward to reviews that see beyond fashion and signalling.
So. Does this change how we give?
*Statisticians like the word "actually" a lot.
This is similar to a position I've seen advanced by Arnold Kling on his Substack, that for-profit enterprises do more good for society than non-profits because they have to provide something people actually need enough to pay for to stay in operation.
ReplyDeleteMy wife and I contribute to a variety of organizations, but the ones I feel most strongly about are the ones that address devastating but solvable afflictions: fixing cleft palates, surgical correction of blindness, etc.
ReplyDelete