One more rant, just a sidebar. Yes, we all know that government workers
don’t do much work. We waste everything,
really, and just go to meetings and eat donuts.
Fair enough. It’s all true.
But most of you work at jobs where people want your services
rather than avoid them. You go to a restaurant because you want food, or shop
online because you are seeking something.
You prepare a report that someone wants.
You repair something or install something that was requested. You
entertain. You heal or alleviate. You steer someone to the person who can help
them, you defend them in court, you evaluate how they might best manage their
money. Sales can be a bit different,
because sometimes you are handling something that people really don’t think
they need, or know they would like, so you have that hurdle to get over. But usually they want something, and sales
difficulty is that they get it from you instead of the next guy. Or the objection is often not that they don’t
want it, but they can’t afford it.
Everyone likes the idea of an orderly, well-run, fair-play
society, but policemen and courts spend a lot of time delivering a service
to people who are uh, actively resisting and not very grateful. Teachers
certainly get some kids glad to be there, but they also put a lot of energy
into getting them to do things they would rather not. When you head to a government agency to get
something and stand in line, it is often not for something that you wanted, but
something you have to have because this agency says so – a registration or a
permission or a license.
Who thanks a prison guard?
This is in the background of size-of-government discussions,
I suspect. Government workers bring you
services you don’t want. Oh, you want
them in theory, because you know what it would be like if all those other
people didn’t have zoning laws or traffic laws. But at the point of delivery, really, you’d
rather not be seeing me, thank you very much, let me go now and I’m not taking
your fucking meds. (Damn cops should be out catching real criminals instead
of…what the hell do they do down at that school all day, anyway?)
Even when it’s a necessary intrusion, a good intrusion, it’s
still us horning in and stopping everyone from running next to the pool. We get used to ignoring you when you
complain, because the last five people also complained about the same thing.
Amen! Tho I suspect some of the same logic is behind "first we shoot all the lawyers". Because happy, well behaved people who aren't hurt or in trouble rarely have to go to law.
ReplyDeleteSometimes I think simple envy of decent health care and at least the promise of future pensions is behind much snarling about "parasitical" governmental workers. What everyone should have, seems unfairly bestowed on that grouchy clerk or administrator.
Mostly it's about denial: government workers deny wishes, and burst bubbles of denial. And bring reality brutally home to people. As TS Eliot said "human nature can not bear very much reality" (sic?)
Good post. I do think that the quality of customer interaction with customer-facing employees is primarily a matter of quality of management. In general, businesses will do this better, both for the reason you state and also because businesses sooner or later face the danger of losing money and even going out of business...but still, some businesses are terrible at this and some government agencies are fairly decent.d
ReplyDeleteMy state DMV (Maryland) is pretty decent.
Another point: government work inherently must be highly proceduralized to avoid corruption and/or tyrannical behavior. Peter Drucker said that "any government that is not a government of paper forms degenerates rapidly into a mutual looting society." (The principle doesn't change if the forms a electronic rather than paper.)
ReplyDeleteYou forgot the inherent feeling that WE'RE PAYING YOUR SALARY. So when government workers do something you don't like, you can act like a betrayed boss.
ReplyDeleteMy Dad seems to get that a lot...don't suspend my license because I PAY YOUR SALARY.
bethany, yes, I get that at the hospital, too, usually from people who are on SSD, APTD, FS, QMB, Medicaid and all the other programs.
ReplyDeleteState property tax is a biggie, also Rooms and Meals and various fees, which I don't think my particular customers figure prominently in. However, alcohol, tobacco, and lottery revenue are often right up their alley, so they may be partially right.
Funny about us lazy gov't workers. Since there wasn't room on campus the IceCube offices are in a downtown office building. When I show up in the morning the lawyers and apartment management company people aren't in their next-door offices yet, and when I leave they've mostly gone home already.
ReplyDeleteSome are; some aren't. I will say I've never had a problem with my local DMV office.
ReplyDelete