Like many other songs of the rural life with puzzling lyrics, you have to dig back into other versions to find that the song is about a young woman who is trying to keep her pretty ploughboy lover from leaving her in the morning. Some versions are more of the wink-wink, nudge-nudge of what a fine life those ploughboys have, showing their healthy limbs off with no shirt in May, other versions are more plaintive, of girls taken advantage of and abandoned. I think the tone of the music favors the latter as more appropriate, and thus likely more original. But there's no guarantee of that in folk music.
No comments:
Post a Comment