Tuesday, October 16, 2012
Deer Crossing
I can almost understand this. School crossing. Pedestrian crossing. Why wouldn't one's initial response be that "Deer Crossing" is much the same? And we all have a coupla dozen things tucked away in our knowledge base that we believe, but if we looked at suspiciously for a minute or two would toss out. My eldest, who is a smart man, recently posted on Facebook that it had just occurred to him what UCLA stood for. Sometimes we just don't look closely.
And yet...this seems a bridge too far. If you are seeing these signs all the time, giving them your attention, and getting worked up enough to start writing letters to the newspaper and calling radio stations, shouldn't it be a basic point...
Aw, screw it. She's just stupid. What do you think when you see the sign "Falling Rocks," or "High Winds?" The state did that on purpose? Too much precedent for her not to know.
Horse Race
I don't think I am especially good at the strategy aspects of politics, and I don't have a lot of interest. The advancement of ideas is more my concern, and in that, a single presidential election may not loom so large.
Yet it occurs to me that Biden's rudeness may have an explanation. The usual Republican explanation, that he is a rude and arrogant person by nature, may be true, of course. But there may have been some calculation. That it did not play well with independents is a distraction. Observers may think that the last few weeks of an election are all about persuading those last few, but I think the politically experienced say it is all about turning out the base at this point. Biden's rudeness was well-received among the partisans. The message may have been "We're going to kick 'em in the balls. We won't work with those bastards for one minute or entertain any of their evil ideas." Chuck Schumer's recent tax comments support this interpretation. The attack dogs are being sent out to let the rubes know who it is they can count on in a fight.
BTW, Biden threw Hillary under the bus, and her recent statements that "I confess, I am a rabbit" are startling. She and Bill play to the main chance. She could have destroyed Obama's campaign in 48 hours, but apparently decided it would destroy her own career as well and is taking one for the team.*
Don't get me wrong. There are conservatives who think that way too. I've listened to years of people complaining that if Bush/Dole/Bush/McCain/Romney would just be a real conservative and tell it like it is they would win in a landslide. The meaning seems to be "I and my friends would then be genuinely excited about voting for 'em, not just reluctantly going along, and I'm sure that excitement would be shared by Americans in general, because they're just regular folk like us." They want red meat. Reading the Huffington Post, it seems pretty apparent there are liberals of similar mind. They aren't so excited by Obama anymore. They still reliably hate Republicans, but they aren't in love anymore and are convinced Obama's pretty much the same old, same old. A percentage won't show up. A little red meat might encourage them. And undecided voters are weird and unpredictable anyway. There're more votes in turning out the base.
I have no way of measuring this, so I'm just blathering, really. If Obama takes the same prepare-to-be-boarded attitude tonight it gives a little support to my theory, but if he stresses that he's the one who plays well with others (hinting that it's those other guys who won't) it neither supports nor undermines my theory. Going on the attack could be evidence infavor, but so could triangulating and sending the VP out as pit bull.
For Democrats, this was 2008:
In 2012? Meh.
(Tangent: I was never much of a Joni Mitchell fan, but this is simply great poetry, and the best version of the song. I knew the oversweet Judi Collins and Clannad versions, but go to Youtube and see. They're all oversweet versions. I don't generally like her style, I don't like that tuning, I really don't like her politics, which are "One Side Forever," but dammit, Joni absolutely gets it right, far more right than even brilliant artists here.)
*She must believe she will not be airbrushed from next spring's May Day photographs.
Yet it occurs to me that Biden's rudeness may have an explanation. The usual Republican explanation, that he is a rude and arrogant person by nature, may be true, of course. But there may have been some calculation. That it did not play well with independents is a distraction. Observers may think that the last few weeks of an election are all about persuading those last few, but I think the politically experienced say it is all about turning out the base at this point. Biden's rudeness was well-received among the partisans. The message may have been "We're going to kick 'em in the balls. We won't work with those bastards for one minute or entertain any of their evil ideas." Chuck Schumer's recent tax comments support this interpretation. The attack dogs are being sent out to let the rubes know who it is they can count on in a fight.
BTW, Biden threw Hillary under the bus, and her recent statements that "I confess, I am a rabbit" are startling. She and Bill play to the main chance. She could have destroyed Obama's campaign in 48 hours, but apparently decided it would destroy her own career as well and is taking one for the team.*
Don't get me wrong. There are conservatives who think that way too. I've listened to years of people complaining that if Bush/Dole/Bush/McCain/Romney would just be a real conservative and tell it like it is they would win in a landslide. The meaning seems to be "I and my friends would then be genuinely excited about voting for 'em, not just reluctantly going along, and I'm sure that excitement would be shared by Americans in general, because they're just regular folk like us." They want red meat. Reading the Huffington Post, it seems pretty apparent there are liberals of similar mind. They aren't so excited by Obama anymore. They still reliably hate Republicans, but they aren't in love anymore and are convinced Obama's pretty much the same old, same old. A percentage won't show up. A little red meat might encourage them. And undecided voters are weird and unpredictable anyway. There're more votes in turning out the base.
I have no way of measuring this, so I'm just blathering, really. If Obama takes the same prepare-to-be-boarded attitude tonight it gives a little support to my theory, but if he stresses that he's the one who plays well with others (hinting that it's those other guys who won't) it neither supports nor undermines my theory. Going on the attack could be evidence infavor, but so could triangulating and sending the VP out as pit bull.
For Democrats, this was 2008:
In 2012? Meh.
(Tangent: I was never much of a Joni Mitchell fan, but this is simply great poetry, and the best version of the song. I knew the oversweet Judi Collins and Clannad versions, but go to Youtube and see. They're all oversweet versions. I don't generally like her style, I don't like that tuning, I really don't like her politics, which are "One Side Forever," but dammit, Joni absolutely gets it right, far more right than even brilliant artists here.)
*She must believe she will not be airbrushed from next spring's May Day photographs.
Friday, October 12, 2012
Wodehouse Prize
The Bollinger Everyman Wodehouse Prize is awarded every year in the UK for comic literature. This sounded like a treasure chest for my Amazon wish-list, but clicking through the descriptions, black comedy and tragicomedy - not even "quirky," which would be the lite versions of those - seem to dominate. A Fraction of The Whole looks like it might be just plain funny, but apparently we don't do that so much anymore.
I don't doubt I would like many of these at least somewhat. Terry Pratchett has always seemed to me to be a cross between Xanth and Hitchhiker's Guide and not so appealing years later, but I have liked bits that I have had described to me. The others listed - except maybe that Ukrainian Tractors thing - seem too drenched in irony, or nuance, or something. Yet, seeing that even I don't like the humorous styles I used to love, it may be the age. Some other generation may have to reclaim simple humor.
Does anyone know anything about the others?
Or you could just comment about book-humor in general.
I don't doubt I would like many of these at least somewhat. Terry Pratchett has always seemed to me to be a cross between Xanth and Hitchhiker's Guide and not so appealing years later, but I have liked bits that I have had described to me. The others listed - except maybe that Ukrainian Tractors thing - seem too drenched in irony, or nuance, or something. Yet, seeing that even I don't like the humorous styles I used to love, it may be the age. Some other generation may have to reclaim simple humor.
Does anyone know anything about the others?
Or you could just comment about book-humor in general.
Nobel Prize
The European Union wins the Nobel Peace Prize.
Strange. Though the institutions are separate (so far as I know), they are both so thoroughly part of the mental furniture of the European liberal that the award seems self-congratulatory.
Strange. Though the institutions are separate (so far as I know), they are both so thoroughly part of the mental furniture of the European liberal that the award seems self-congratulatory.
Wednesday, October 10, 2012
Derek Jeter and 4,000 hits
Pete Rose does some arithmetic, and he's right, but I still want to take any opportunity to kick him. Yes, Jeter will not pass him for hits - won't even make it to 4,000 - but how did this question come up? Is Pete Rose the bride at every wedding or something? Jeter's response is the correct one.
Second, that particular record and the overall value of Pete Rose are overrated. Not valueless - it's a significant accomplishment. It's just not top shelf.
Plus he's just always been a jerk.
Second, that particular record and the overall value of Pete Rose are overrated. Not valueless - it's a significant accomplishment. It's just not top shelf.
Plus he's just always been a jerk.
Cato's Rating of Governors
The Cato Institute has a white paper, rating the governors on fiscal responsibility. Summary here.
There are some interesting entries. It is not surprising, given that it's Cato, that Republicans score better than Democrats on this. But don't jump to conclusions, because Cato has never been hesitant to go where the numbers lead. This highest-ranking Democrat is NH's John Lynch, tied for fifth with Bobby Jindal. That's ahead of Rick Perry in Texas, for those of you scoring at home. Not only that, but Deval Patrick of Massachusetts is also well ahead of Perry, garnering one of the few "B's" the Dems earned. I am surprised, but I tip my hat.
The five "F's" all go to Democrats, but 3 Republicans plus (ahem) Independent Lincoln Chafee of Rhode Island got a "D." The scores range from 16 to 69, with Republicans averaging 57 and Democrats 43.
There are some interesting entries. It is not surprising, given that it's Cato, that Republicans score better than Democrats on this. But don't jump to conclusions, because Cato has never been hesitant to go where the numbers lead. This highest-ranking Democrat is NH's John Lynch, tied for fifth with Bobby Jindal. That's ahead of Rick Perry in Texas, for those of you scoring at home. Not only that, but Deval Patrick of Massachusetts is also well ahead of Perry, garnering one of the few "B's" the Dems earned. I am surprised, but I tip my hat.
The five "F's" all go to Democrats, but 3 Republicans plus (ahem) Independent Lincoln Chafee of Rhode Island got a "D." The scores range from 16 to 69, with Republicans averaging 57 and Democrats 43.
We Are Doomed
I liked a great deal of John Derbyshire's book. He hails from a branch of conservatism that has had to sit in the corridor much of the last decade, more paleocon than neocon. Derb himself might say metrocon, a word he coined that never caught on, as he relates in this book.
He is quite serious in his belief that We Are Doomed, in the sense that we are past the point of no return in more than one area in America, and the West in general. Though pessimistic, he is not despairing, and has tips on how we are to buck ourselves up in the partial, though inevitable collapse he sees coming - a collapse that is as much cultural as financial.
But this isn't a review, but an occasion to spin off and discuss a part of the book I not only disagree with, but think that Derb has lost the objectivity he insists on in others. He was once a Christian believer of some mild C of E sort, but has no definitively decided he is not. I am certainly likely to look at such reasoning with heightened suspiciousness, though even I have acknowledged some folk who have taken that path remain somewhat reasonable. I tend toward the Thomist idea that perfect reason must lead to God, however - my bias that causes me to be extra hard on that line of thought.
The first red flag went up when he asserted that all religions have creation and world-ending myths, that they are rather easily knocked down by science, and thus the Christian story should be held in similar regard. This is simply not factually true. Some religions - notably some of the Native American tribal beliefs - have creation myths that are important to the whole picture. But even a moment's thought will reveal that the mythologies we know most about - Roman, Greek, Norse - make scant mention of such things. Extra points if you remembered Yggdrasil, but even that has only occasional mention and is not the ultimate beginning - just beginningish. The Eastern religions are quite cyclic and repeating, as most religions are. Beginning, middle, and end are more western ideas. They are not entirely absent in the East, but it is mostly westerners who are fascinated by them.
In fact, many of the supposed creation stories only seem to have come into prominence once Christians started asking "How do you chaps think the world got started, then? And where's it all going?" I don't want to oversell this. There are religions with solid creation ideas, and most of the major ones have at least something we can point to, especially around the Mediterranean. But they don't figure in the literature much beyond their first few mentions - Hesiod, for example.
Small point, Mr. Derbyshire, but one with large implications. As I posted recently, any two things can look similar if you squint hard enough. Selection bias and confirmation bias are powerful. Beginning, middle, end is not exclusively western, but it is dominantly so.
Which brings me to my more basic point: we all tend to adopt the beliefs of those we hang out with. As an evolutionary strategy, this is the safe choice. The tribe may need the occasional person to think outside the box, and will carry the genes for that, but it tends to be a risky survival strategy. While acknowledging that some scientists remain (or become) Christians, he notes that these are far fewer than in the population at large. The biologists and neuroscientists in particular have low percentages of believers, and he feels they should be the most reliable evaluators of human thought.
Except that a strongly related group, medical doctors, including the neurologists, hold confessional beliefs at rates similar to the general population. Derb doesn't hang out with this group, so he believes what the academic biologists hint to him is the norm: unbelief. I don't mean to be harsh on him as any worse than the rest of us, all huddling together with the like-minded and believing what is socially comfortable, but neither is it any better. Not in the least. Therefore, one shouldn't make a big deal out of claiming your group is somehow different when writing a book.
In a pure argument, I think Mr. Derbyshire would take the point and agree with it at least partly. But that would be a purely theoretical agreement. From his tone in writing, it is clear that for all his doubt about consciousness and solidity and untrustworthiness of thought, he thinks this (un)belief is really true. They really are the experts, and I'm with them.
I've made the point often and don't need to hammer it. Beliefs have their fashions, and these are often more powerful movers of opinion that logic. The song from South Pacific is dead wrong about racial prejudice: you don't have to be carefully taught. It's the prejudice that is natural, attested in all literatures as far back as we can trace. Racial prejudice went away in our society largely because it became unfashionable, not because there were lengthy logical debates and persuasions about it. The James Micheners of the world had a belief and sold it. There's a cart-and-horse question here, because they received the idea from parts of their culture as well, but you take my point. A single artist is seldom powerful, but in the aggregate, artists change the culture. In this case, they made racial prejudice unfashionable. Hard to argue with that, but it still isn't reasoning.
It may be the best we poor humans can do, however.
In my own lifetime the same thing has happened with acceptance of homosexuality. Movies and theater, more than books and music, has had a great deal to do with this. But those media have not engaged us in debate or intellectual consideration of the topic (though they sometimes pretend to portray this), they have simply convinced us that it is unfashionable to disapprove of homosexuality and immoral to forbid it in any context. Credit or blame whoever you want on this, but the culture as a whole went along.
One important addition: we all belong to several groups, and it will often happen that we feel conflicted about who we will ultimately side with. It is an interesting general problem, but I am much more interested in how it plays out when one of the belief-sets is Christianity, or what the individual believes is the Christian norm. People get converted to conservatism or liberalism - or conspiracy theories or parenting styles or socialism - along with their Christianity, and many don't separate these out very well. Again, it is a hard thing to go against the group one looks to for mates and jobs and companionship.
Sometimes the choices can be revealing. Sometimes you can sense that a person has not rejected the faith as taught, but has, without realising it, put their church membership second to some other group. I have been most aware of this when watching how wealthier parents choose to have their children raised. Depending on the prevailing culture, that may be aspirational parents sending their children to religious schools though they are only somewhat religious, or might be previously religious parents who start thinking that getting children into the "best" schools is their real allegiance.
He is quite serious in his belief that We Are Doomed, in the sense that we are past the point of no return in more than one area in America, and the West in general. Though pessimistic, he is not despairing, and has tips on how we are to buck ourselves up in the partial, though inevitable collapse he sees coming - a collapse that is as much cultural as financial.
But this isn't a review, but an occasion to spin off and discuss a part of the book I not only disagree with, but think that Derb has lost the objectivity he insists on in others. He was once a Christian believer of some mild C of E sort, but has no definitively decided he is not. I am certainly likely to look at such reasoning with heightened suspiciousness, though even I have acknowledged some folk who have taken that path remain somewhat reasonable. I tend toward the Thomist idea that perfect reason must lead to God, however - my bias that causes me to be extra hard on that line of thought.
The first red flag went up when he asserted that all religions have creation and world-ending myths, that they are rather easily knocked down by science, and thus the Christian story should be held in similar regard. This is simply not factually true. Some religions - notably some of the Native American tribal beliefs - have creation myths that are important to the whole picture. But even a moment's thought will reveal that the mythologies we know most about - Roman, Greek, Norse - make scant mention of such things. Extra points if you remembered Yggdrasil, but even that has only occasional mention and is not the ultimate beginning - just beginningish. The Eastern religions are quite cyclic and repeating, as most religions are. Beginning, middle, and end are more western ideas. They are not entirely absent in the East, but it is mostly westerners who are fascinated by them.
In fact, many of the supposed creation stories only seem to have come into prominence once Christians started asking "How do you chaps think the world got started, then? And where's it all going?" I don't want to oversell this. There are religions with solid creation ideas, and most of the major ones have at least something we can point to, especially around the Mediterranean. But they don't figure in the literature much beyond their first few mentions - Hesiod, for example.
Small point, Mr. Derbyshire, but one with large implications. As I posted recently, any two things can look similar if you squint hard enough. Selection bias and confirmation bias are powerful. Beginning, middle, end is not exclusively western, but it is dominantly so.
Which brings me to my more basic point: we all tend to adopt the beliefs of those we hang out with. As an evolutionary strategy, this is the safe choice. The tribe may need the occasional person to think outside the box, and will carry the genes for that, but it tends to be a risky survival strategy. While acknowledging that some scientists remain (or become) Christians, he notes that these are far fewer than in the population at large. The biologists and neuroscientists in particular have low percentages of believers, and he feels they should be the most reliable evaluators of human thought.
Except that a strongly related group, medical doctors, including the neurologists, hold confessional beliefs at rates similar to the general population. Derb doesn't hang out with this group, so he believes what the academic biologists hint to him is the norm: unbelief. I don't mean to be harsh on him as any worse than the rest of us, all huddling together with the like-minded and believing what is socially comfortable, but neither is it any better. Not in the least. Therefore, one shouldn't make a big deal out of claiming your group is somehow different when writing a book.
In a pure argument, I think Mr. Derbyshire would take the point and agree with it at least partly. But that would be a purely theoretical agreement. From his tone in writing, it is clear that for all his doubt about consciousness and solidity and untrustworthiness of thought, he thinks this (un)belief is really true. They really are the experts, and I'm with them.
I've made the point often and don't need to hammer it. Beliefs have their fashions, and these are often more powerful movers of opinion that logic. The song from South Pacific is dead wrong about racial prejudice: you don't have to be carefully taught. It's the prejudice that is natural, attested in all literatures as far back as we can trace. Racial prejudice went away in our society largely because it became unfashionable, not because there were lengthy logical debates and persuasions about it. The James Micheners of the world had a belief and sold it. There's a cart-and-horse question here, because they received the idea from parts of their culture as well, but you take my point. A single artist is seldom powerful, but in the aggregate, artists change the culture. In this case, they made racial prejudice unfashionable. Hard to argue with that, but it still isn't reasoning.
It may be the best we poor humans can do, however.
In my own lifetime the same thing has happened with acceptance of homosexuality. Movies and theater, more than books and music, has had a great deal to do with this. But those media have not engaged us in debate or intellectual consideration of the topic (though they sometimes pretend to portray this), they have simply convinced us that it is unfashionable to disapprove of homosexuality and immoral to forbid it in any context. Credit or blame whoever you want on this, but the culture as a whole went along.
One important addition: we all belong to several groups, and it will often happen that we feel conflicted about who we will ultimately side with. It is an interesting general problem, but I am much more interested in how it plays out when one of the belief-sets is Christianity, or what the individual believes is the Christian norm. People get converted to conservatism or liberalism - or conspiracy theories or parenting styles or socialism - along with their Christianity, and many don't separate these out very well. Again, it is a hard thing to go against the group one looks to for mates and jobs and companionship.
Sometimes the choices can be revealing. Sometimes you can sense that a person has not rejected the faith as taught, but has, without realising it, put their church membership second to some other group. I have been most aware of this when watching how wealthier parents choose to have their children raised. Depending on the prevailing culture, that may be aspirational parents sending their children to religious schools though they are only somewhat religious, or might be previously religious parents who start thinking that getting children into the "best" schools is their real allegiance.
Monday, October 08, 2012
Empty Suit
Sponge-Headed Scienceman (or perhaps his wife) sent this along.
Sunday, October 07, 2012
It's A Dog's Life
My son sent this link to the one episode of this 1979 sitcom (get it? Sit - com? I slay me.) Screenwriter/announcer Ken Levine gives a little background at the link. This is so awful, the comments were focused on how long you could last before you couldn't take anymore.
I went five minutes and could easily have gone more if I weren't in a hurry. I grew up on stupid TV sitcoms. I can watch them all day - and did. It's really hard to get below my threshold.
I went five minutes and could easily have gone more if I weren't in a hurry. I grew up on stupid TV sitcoms. I can watch them all day - and did. It's really hard to get below my threshold.
Rich People
Let me tell you about the very rich. They are different from you and me. They possess and enjoy early, and it does something to them, makes them soft where we are hard, and cynical where we are trustful, in a way that, unless you were born rich, it is very difficult to understand. They think, deep in their hearts, that they are better than we are because we had to discover the compensations and refuges of life for ourselves. Even when they enter deep into our world or sink below us, they still think that they are better than we are. They are different. "Rich Boy" F. Scott FitzgeraldI have a little experience with the very rich. Most of us do have some chance associations based on where we have lived or worked or gone to school, the families we come from, or the hobbies we have. I don't know that mine is much more extensive than any of yours. We rub shoulders with the wealthy. More rarely, with the uberrich - I can't say I know much about them.
Similarly, most of us have occasional contact with the moderately wealthy - people who don't necessarily see themselves as all that rich - because they are in contact with people much richer - but by all objective measures are among the most prosperous folks in the country and certainly, the world. We talk about the 1%, but in world terms, we are all among the 5%, and historically, the 1%. Few people think of themselves as rich.
I am uncertain how much I agree with the quote above. Putting aside Fitzgerald's personal reasons for a love-hate relationship with the rich, treating the quote as a generic observation by some anonymous writer, it seems partly true at first glance. I have certainly known folks who have that air of entitlement, of deserving the choicest portions because they can pay for them, even if they never disparage others or make claims of superiority. We go to church in a wealthy community, where rather expensive cars, homes, or vacations are considered everyday by some. It is troubling at times to be brought up short, noticing that this person has a rather skewed idea of what is normal, I think, and not a lot of obvious gratitude that they should be so lucky as to have their abilities match their time and place so well.
Yet they aren't all like that, and I wonder if we do not simply notice such things more among the wealthy. A (female) coworker of indisputable kindness remarked years ago how tragic the death of a young woman was: "She was so pretty and personable." I remember thinking it would be equally tragic if she weren't pretty. We hear similar words about intelligent people being struck down by some illness or misfortune, as if this somehow makes it worse. Perhaps we mean it that way, though we know we shouldn't, but I think a more likely explanation is that we notice it. Thus with even mildly irritating characteristics among the rich.
OTOH, it is certainly true that exposing people to more temptations means a percentage of them with succumb. The rich with an inflated sense of desert may not do any worse than we would in their shoes, but the point is they aren't in our shoes. They have that temptation and we don't. It would thus be surprising if the wealthy - collectively, not individually - weren't slightly worse than average on this measure, because they have been exposed to temptations the average person hasn't.
I sense, I feel, I smell, that the rich are different in their attitudes, and not in a good way. But selective bias and confirmation bias are likely to be so strong in me that I mistrust it. Perhaps I am projecting my own weaknesses on others, but I have to suspect that much of the current class envy, class-warfare rhetoric of our era plays on the same biases. People think they know what the rich are like and how they think..But they may not.
Saturday, October 06, 2012
Train Song
The Pips. does Gary Trudeau think he could do even a bad imitation of this?
Homophonic Influence
Boston opened its NBA preseason losing to a Turkish team. They have been surprisingly popular in that country for years, even before they had Semih Erden. You can come up with a dozen theories, but I have always leaned to the linguistic one. The team name sounds a lot like Seljuks.
There's a comic bit in there, I suppose.
There's a comic bit in there, I suppose.
The Vision of the Anointed*
The key to liberalism is the belief that if we would just improve services, all the children would be above average.
Keillor's use of this idea has an added meaning that makes it richer, I think, and not an example of the above. It is not only that everyone favors their own children just a bit and sees even the average child as something better. The opposite value is in play as well: don't be too full of yourself, don't put on airs. You're not some genius, you're just above average. When both ideas exist in tension, I don't think it's such a bad thing.
*Title stolen from Thomas Sowell.
Keillor's use of this idea has an added meaning that makes it richer, I think, and not an example of the above. It is not only that everyone favors their own children just a bit and sees even the average child as something better. The opposite value is in play as well: don't be too full of yourself, don't put on airs. You're not some genius, you're just above average. When both ideas exist in tension, I don't think it's such a bad thing.
*Title stolen from Thomas Sowell.
Friday, October 05, 2012
Old Lefty
I work with a social worker about my age who comes from the old school. A lot of those things we believed in the 70's have not fully dislodged, just been given an updated spin. Thursday it was the idea that the military operates on the same principle as gangs, fostering camaraderie and group rules, substitute family... and he delights in making it be "gangs" every time he announces this, not accepting my hints that all groups, clans, tribes, and associations also work from the same basic principles. Plus, he always goes on to mention that the military "targets the most vulnerable members of our society" for membership. He doesn't say it meanly, just patiently explaining it to all of us who might not have grasped the deep truths he is explaining to us.
Today, when I mentioned that in 1990's Romania people were kept in hospital for long periods of time, mostly because not much real medical help could be given and families needed a break from care, so the hospital waited a polite amount of time before sending them home. It also gave the patient some attention and a feeling of being treated well. My colleague thought this was an excellent example of how our Western intrusion had not been entirely positive: Oh, I know it's been economically better but they've lost something that was valuable. His thinking was that families took care of each other more under the old regime, and we disrupted their adaptive patterns.
That this is exactly backward - that the hospitals were not adopting some modern Western idea but were perpetuating an older socialist one - did not occur to him. That I wasn't speaking about elders in the least went unnoticed. That in all societies, care for elder relatives declines as life expectancy increases - went missing. That no Romanian would endorse his opinion as being anything other than insane he is unaware of. Only his previous narrative remains - that there were good things in the old Soviet system that we blindly ignore now because of our simplistic, uninformed narrative.
Today, when I mentioned that in 1990's Romania people were kept in hospital for long periods of time, mostly because not much real medical help could be given and families needed a break from care, so the hospital waited a polite amount of time before sending them home. It also gave the patient some attention and a feeling of being treated well. My colleague thought this was an excellent example of how our Western intrusion had not been entirely positive: Oh, I know it's been economically better but they've lost something that was valuable. His thinking was that families took care of each other more under the old regime, and we disrupted their adaptive patterns.
That this is exactly backward - that the hospitals were not adopting some modern Western idea but were perpetuating an older socialist one - did not occur to him. That I wasn't speaking about elders in the least went unnoticed. That in all societies, care for elder relatives declines as life expectancy increases - went missing. That no Romanian would endorse his opinion as being anything other than insane he is unaware of. Only his previous narrative remains - that there were good things in the old Soviet system that we blindly ignore now because of our simplistic, uninformed narrative.
Similarity
Any two things can be made to look similar if you squint hard enough.
By The Numbers
The season is over, the numbers are now final, and I like to poke around at them. I did not watch an entire at-bat of a Sox game this season. I do listen to sports radio, but they were continually convinced that communication problems were the core of Red Sox troubles, so I switched stations among the three available a lot. The Red Sox had getting people out problems, full stop.
I did hear things along the way. I heard that Daniel Bard wanted to be a starter (they make 3-4 times as much, I understand) and it didn't work. It is always easy to say in retrospect that we should have gone north when it is clear that south didn't work, but I claim to have seen a problem with their method from the start. He was essentially a rookie as a starter, and the place for rookies is in spot starts and long relief. But the Red Sox thought they were contenders, and they needed Bard to be a middle of the rotation player, so they shoved him in there. If you knew you weren't a contender and were developing players and seeing who could pitch for a year, Bard's 5.68 ERA is not that terrible and worth fighting through. Now they've apparently ruined his head and he can't get guys out in AAA.
Similarly, they needed Buchholz or Lester (and now Lackey) to be top-of-the-rotation guys and that looks bleak. Adding in Doubront, Boston now has four fully capable 3rd - 5th starters, and could have had five. They are fine if you just see them for what they are. ERA 4.50 - 5.00, 200 innings for a .500 ball club. Sort that out for one more year and contend again in 2014. What's your problem? You need a #1 and a #2 starter, at least one of whom can eat innings, and you actually have the flexibility to trade 2 of those current guys, because you have another spot-starter long relief guy available (see below). Heck, with Barnes, Webster, and De La Rosa looking almost ready, you have lots of halfway-decent pitchers you can trade. All depth, no top.
For relief pitchers, Tazawa is 26, had an ERA of 1.43 in 44 IP. How is he not your closer, or at least your set-up guy? Problem solved. Atchison if he's healthy and Hill both deserve the same number of innings or more. ERA's under 2. Ride that wave. Breslow has 63 IP - a good number - at 2.70 ERA.
Then there are four players right about the same age who have limited strengths, but would be fine in designated roles. Miller is 6-7 and gets the first batter out all the time. He is still good on the second batter and maybe the third. Mortensen is not only a very good pitcher on 2 or more days' rest, he can go more than two innings if need be. Long relief. Melancon and Carpenter both did well late. They round out your bullpen.
GM's like to play around, bringing in this, that, getting a guy for cheap, etc. I hope no one on the Red Sox puts any energy into thinking about that. Top starters. Eat innings. Pay money. Do that. The rest is in place, with a decent number of developing players on the way.
I did hear things along the way. I heard that Daniel Bard wanted to be a starter (they make 3-4 times as much, I understand) and it didn't work. It is always easy to say in retrospect that we should have gone north when it is clear that south didn't work, but I claim to have seen a problem with their method from the start. He was essentially a rookie as a starter, and the place for rookies is in spot starts and long relief. But the Red Sox thought they were contenders, and they needed Bard to be a middle of the rotation player, so they shoved him in there. If you knew you weren't a contender and were developing players and seeing who could pitch for a year, Bard's 5.68 ERA is not that terrible and worth fighting through. Now they've apparently ruined his head and he can't get guys out in AAA.
Similarly, they needed Buchholz or Lester (and now Lackey) to be top-of-the-rotation guys and that looks bleak. Adding in Doubront, Boston now has four fully capable 3rd - 5th starters, and could have had five. They are fine if you just see them for what they are. ERA 4.50 - 5.00, 200 innings for a .500 ball club. Sort that out for one more year and contend again in 2014. What's your problem? You need a #1 and a #2 starter, at least one of whom can eat innings, and you actually have the flexibility to trade 2 of those current guys, because you have another spot-starter long relief guy available (see below). Heck, with Barnes, Webster, and De La Rosa looking almost ready, you have lots of halfway-decent pitchers you can trade. All depth, no top.
For relief pitchers, Tazawa is 26, had an ERA of 1.43 in 44 IP. How is he not your closer, or at least your set-up guy? Problem solved. Atchison if he's healthy and Hill both deserve the same number of innings or more. ERA's under 2. Ride that wave. Breslow has 63 IP - a good number - at 2.70 ERA.
Then there are four players right about the same age who have limited strengths, but would be fine in designated roles. Miller is 6-7 and gets the first batter out all the time. He is still good on the second batter and maybe the third. Mortensen is not only a very good pitcher on 2 or more days' rest, he can go more than two innings if need be. Long relief. Melancon and Carpenter both did well late. They round out your bullpen.
GM's like to play around, bringing in this, that, getting a guy for cheap, etc. I hope no one on the Red Sox puts any energy into thinking about that. Top starters. Eat innings. Pay money. Do that. The rest is in place, with a decent number of developing players on the way.
Thursday, October 04, 2012
Hurling
The All-Ireland Senior Hurling Championship Final was recently completed. This gives me a chance to reprise a 2006 post on attending a hurling match in Dublin, Games Mad. It does seem I am the only one who likes it so much.
The language of sporting events in other English-speaking countries is always a bit unnerving, but always entertaining. I am guessing that describing Walter Walsh as a debutant has a different meaning in Ireland than America. A rookie, we would say. And "Galway's Cyril Donnellan was shown the red card and sent off after swinging his hurley at opponent J. J. Delaney and hitting him upon the head" does suggest why the sport remains popular, doesn't it?
The crowds of 80,000 are only for the major matches, apparently. The one we attended had less than ten, including the four of us. Very odd.
The language of sporting events in other English-speaking countries is always a bit unnerving, but always entertaining. I am guessing that describing Walter Walsh as a debutant has a different meaning in Ireland than America. A rookie, we would say. And "Galway's Cyril Donnellan was shown the red card and sent off after swinging his hurley at opponent J. J. Delaney and hitting him upon the head" does suggest why the sport remains popular, doesn't it?
The crowds of 80,000 are only for the major matches, apparently. The one we attended had less than ten, including the four of us. Very odd.
Sunday, September 30, 2012
Runs Scored, Runs Against Revisited
Everyone finally got on the bandwagon to marvel at scrappy Baltimore, that lovable overachieving bunch winning games with Pluck despite their poor run differential. Except that's no longer true. That was true in May and June only. It was partly the case in April, July, and August, but not so you'd notice.
In September they've had a run differential over 50, and have picked up 10 more games over .500 in the W-L rankings. That's not can-do spirit, that's just beating the cookies out of people.
Baltimore manager of yore Earl Weaver used to say that "chemistry" in baseball was simple: GP + 3R = W. Good pitching plus 3-run homers equals wins.
In September they've had a run differential over 50, and have picked up 10 more games over .500 in the W-L rankings. That's not can-do spirit, that's just beating the cookies out of people.
Baltimore manager of yore Earl Weaver used to say that "chemistry" in baseball was simple: GP + 3R = W. Good pitching plus 3-run homers equals wins.
Thursday, September 27, 2012
All-Fenway Team
The all-time All- Fenway Park Red Sox team was announced this week. It favors players in living memory of baby boomers or younger unless an earlier player was so ridiculously overqualified that we have to take the time to educate the younger generation about them, because they simply cannot be left off. Jimmy Foxx. Lefty Grove. Smokey Joe Wood. Dom Dimaggio. And of course, Ted Williams.
I get that. I even agree with it, because otherwise you start to get arguments for people who had two good seasons and were just sort of useful for a few others. I might think Mel Parnell should be on there, but even I don't want to get into discussing Pete Runnels, Ellis Kinder, Walt Dropo. Nobody cares.
Plus, I loved Reggie Smith and Trot Nixon, so it's great to see them remembered. I don't know if Nixon, especially, really was the 2nd best RF in Fenway history, but I'm not minded to quibble. You can make an argument for it.
I have only one problem with this. Tris Speaker. Yes, he only had four years at Fenway and most of his stats were amassed for Cleveland. But those four years included the inaugural year of the ballpark, which should count for something, and those four years were quite something.
I get that. I even agree with it, because otherwise you start to get arguments for people who had two good seasons and were just sort of useful for a few others. I might think Mel Parnell should be on there, but even I don't want to get into discussing Pete Runnels, Ellis Kinder, Walt Dropo. Nobody cares.
Plus, I loved Reggie Smith and Trot Nixon, so it's great to see them remembered. I don't know if Nixon, especially, really was the 2nd best RF in Fenway history, but I'm not minded to quibble. You can make an argument for it.
I have only one problem with this. Tris Speaker. Yes, he only had four years at Fenway and most of his stats were amassed for Cleveland. But those four years included the inaugural year of the ballpark, which should count for something, and those four years were quite something.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)