Sunday, December 09, 2012

Racial Consciousness


The Audacious Epigone noted in passing, halfway down the linked post, that he is detecting an increase in a sense of racial identity among white people of his generation.  I had not quite thought of it that way, but immediately thought he is correct in this.  I think I am detecting the same thing.  I consider this a bad thing, even dire, for America.  I suspect he automatic assumption is that such consciousness of race is primarily, or even necessarily, anti-black or anti-Hispanic.  I don’t think that is much true, and says more about the assumers than the assumees. Still, it's all a bad thing.

I am already well ahead of myself.  Let me trace the history from my earliest training.  I was taught that we are all Americans, with equal rights, and all in this together.  Some people didn’t want black people to have the same rights, but they were wrong.  This was known to be more common in the South, but present everywhere. There had recently (this was the 50's and 60's) been some legitimate argument whether people from one part of the country should make people from another part of the country be fair whether they liked it or not, and some dispute about speed.  Yet because bad people had hid behind some plausible arguments, the decent people had pretty much abandoned them.  The goal was that black people should be mainstream Americans, because they weren’t really any different.  Red and yellow, black and white, they are precious in His sight, etc. Decent people who were also alert made a special effort not to be accidentally unkind to black people, who had been kicked enough.  Sometimes they fell over themselves being kind.  This was regarded as clumsy and gauche, but essentially well-meant.

Somewhere in the 70’s, the idea came around that this wasn’t the right solution.  Because those decent white people were unconsciously assuming everyone was like them, that was prejudice too.  It was a package with assuming maleness to “mankind,” or Christianity to “religion,” or other ways of leaving some people out of the picture, even without intending to.

It is hard to recreate what I thought then, or how things changed, but I’ll have a go at it.  I thought that dividing up Americans was a step backward, but I saw the point.  It was true that my picture of Americans was something of a portrait of my own circle, not really including the others, and I can see why it felt insulting to not be included.  They were, after all, just as validly American as I was.  Plus, I figured, I’m from New Hampshire, what do I know?  People who deal with this as part of their daily lives must just know better than I what the best way forward is.

Let me interject here the important point that the foregoing is clearly ridiculous and impossible.  There never were any decent white people who thought this way, they were all unconsciously racist and they should have no voice now.  (See how jarring that sentiment is when it is in the context of a real person, rather than a set of people to be lumped for purpose of political gain? )

I’ve read for years about people who note that other American groups have identities in order to increase political power, white people should do the same.  I’ve always thought that was fringey and ridiculous, and wondered if the sentiment were not more anti-black than pro-white.  I don’t know much about such folks, they just turn up once in awhile, so I can’t say I know what they are thinking.  However, I do think that’s an enormous step backward for America. But looking at it, I don’t know how any other result could be expected when dividing up Americans became the ideal.  Not that everyone would mentally divide themselves out, but that some would.  Isn’t that a rather natural result of being told that your reasons are not your real reasons, and the tone of glee that the former mainstreamers are no longer numerically ahead, as if that in itself were some advance?  I don’t think it has any effect on whether people are for or against other races or groups.  Those who were, remain so, those who weren’t, remain that.  But I think something subtler does occur.  White people decide that they aren’t the ones misunderstanding others.  They look around and think “No, I understand them fine.  It’s they who don’t understand me, always accusing.”

I don’t attribute this to Obama or his blackness, BTW.  I now think this is a trend that has been building for decades, recently efflourescing.  Maybe it’s a little faster because of the accident of the particular players, but I they didn’t start the fire. 

***     ***

I am ahead of myself again, or at least, verging into other territory.  Let me get back on track about racial consciousness.  Ideas we acquire are not necessarily inexorable, just because we can trace their roots far back.  I have a racial sidebar that remained a mere curiosity for twenty years or so, only emerging as the red state-blue state divide arose and became especially vitriolic starting in 2004.

I am an evangelical, but I have always considered myself to be an unusual specimen.  Not rare, because I have been able to find other evangelicals at least somewhat like me, but not comfortable in the music, books, and tapes of popular evangelical culture.  Still, I have some identification with the group, and so always perked up my ears around surveys and statistics about evangelical beliefs and behaviors.  Sometime in the 80’s, there was this article about young evangelicals, going out of its way to point out what hypocrites they were, because their illegitimacy rate was just as high as mainstream denominations and nonreligious.  So hahaha. But about a week before, I had read a separate article in a nonreligious but political magazine, complaining that sociological studies did not break out religious groups by race, because those called “evangelical” or “fundamentalist” tended to be either all black or all white, and very different socially and politically.

So I wondered if the illegitimacy study had been broken out by race.  I was ashamed of myself for even wondering, and never mentioned it anywhere.  Polite people didn’t mention such things.  It might indeed prove that it was a more typically black illegitimacy rate in those churches, but they were our Christian brothers and sisters, and we weren’t going to kick them when they were down.  We stand together.  It was not until some years later, I think during the Clinton election that someone suddenly did break those numbers out by race, and they were appalling.  I remember thinking “Well, no one on the left is going to want that to get out.  That’s the last we’ll hear about that.”  But it kept coming, and the implication was clear: those white yahoos from Mississippi and South Carolina are just self-righteous hypocrites. Look at all this state-by-state pathology.

God forgive me, I believed that too.  I knew at some level that this wasn’t quite right, and sometimes remembered it, but it occupied a separate part of my mind.  New Hampshire has the highest SAT’s in the nation, or 2nd-lowest dropout rate, yeah, eat our dust, Arkansas! (Polite people can have ugly prejudices against some groups after all, eh?)  You can see the real numbers on white IQ’s bystate over at The Audacious Epigone, BTW. The stereotype generally holds, but much more weakly than advertised.  The entire range is 98-103.  Not very big.

As I was leaving liberalism, I still held – in some ways still hold – that prejudice.  Even knowing that the numbers for whites in different states were not all that different, I still pinned the more dramatic numbers on my picture of their typical citizen.  But in the last few years, the opposite has become automatic: Red States are net receivers of government aid compared to Blue States, we are told with a sneer.  I now ask “Does that include military installations?  Veterans’ benefits? Is that broken out by number of illegal immigrants?  Is that broken out by race?” And so on. Obesity. Diabetes. Educational attainment. Special Ed. Disability claims. Crime rates.  Illegitimacy. Divorce rates.   I suspect that when liberal white people from Vermont try to make political hay out of such things, the recipients often knew “Oh, so now you’re making it racial (or NAM in general).   You don’t know that, but that’s what you just did.  If I point that out, I’ll be the bad guy, but you just reminded me once again.”  The difference is that  the nonliberal white people in Vermont have started noticing it too, because such a big deal is being made of the pathology of being the wrong sort of white person.

We have long all politely not mentioned that “the problem of our cities” has a strong racial and ethnic piece.  It’s just not nice, and there doesn’t seem to be any point.  But now that’s moving up to the state level, in a bitterly divided country, and whiteness is being specifically described as a problem.  I don’t like being described as a problem when I haven’t done anything wrong.  The irony is, those people who for reasons of fashion devote much energy and vitriol into demonstrating that they are not the bad sort of white person, by identifying out, are actually intensifying the phenomenon.

Friday, December 07, 2012

Fashion Definition

Bethany's comment highlighted for me something I had not explained well in my theory of fashion in politics.  I am including long-term fashions, trends, if you will, as well as the ephemeral Monkees/BSB/1D variety.  Deep fashion, if you will, more in line with the fashion she notes in which areas of the brain it is now considered sexy to study. In the 1940's and 50's and into the 60's it was more fashionable to be accepted into the mainstream of American culture, and one can observe the strivings of the outsiders to cement their place.  Since then, it has been more fashionable to be a bit outside - sometimes extremely outside, but not very often, and not among many.  These days, to be a bit different in some way is the ticket.

It isn't an either-or proposition.  There has always been a cultural tension in Western society between being one of the accepteds versus being one of the rebels, and I doubt it ever goes farther than 60-40 in either direction.  Assortive mating is a strong controller to keep both in play.  But by the fashionableness of Democrats, I don't merely mean the Obama Rock Star campaign stops (though I will include those as well), but the anti-fashion fashionableness of those who think themselves far above such plebian excesses.

Messages

What is the thinking behind seeing that a call came in and a message was left, and calling back the number instead of listening to the message?  It may be somewhat generational, but I know people my age who do it as well.  It's just weird.  "I saw you called."  Well yeah, I did, and I left a precise message.  Why didn't you listen to that first?

Update:  My commenters have convinced me.  I withdraw my objection.

Thursday, December 06, 2012

Again With the "Fashionable Politics."


As I noted, I meant my declaration about fashionable politics to sting.  I really do consider it bad for the country to do business that way, and wish to shame others into not approving of such social and emotional, rather than logical appeals.

I think attacks on my position might form along the following lines: 

1.   Fashionable is an unnecessarily inflammatory and objectionable term.  Some other descriptor would be fairer, something along the lines of “represents the ideas of a majority of Americans well”.
2.  Relatedly, what I am describing as “fashion” includes an array of values that Democrats believe they should be trying to sell in any way possible.  Trivialising them with language is an attempt to trivialize important moral questions.
3.  Some liberal values are actually unpopular, and must overcome an inertial cultural drag against them. They are many, not few, and cannot be easily generalized.
4.  The fashionableness is true but trivial: every election winner captured a greater percentage of low-information voters, almost by definition.  Obama won a majority of knuckleheads this time, but Bush won them before that, and presumably, Buchanan won more of those than John Fremont and Millard Fillmore. This is the “Yes, but so what?” argument.

Can you think of others?  I am asking you to refrain from any refutation of these criticisms at present - I plan to have fun doing that myself – but I am trying to get a full picture of what might dash my ideas to the floor, and also, to get a better wording for these lines of attack.  Please humor me. Reading Fashionable Politics, what occurs to you as possible weaknesses or unfairness?

Interruption

I was going to post further thought on political fashionableness, but got fascinated by Steve Sailer's new string of posts on "What caused the 60's?" It's a fun parlour game, and anyone can play, of course, because so many plausible theories can be brought forward.

Here's the catch: a commenter mentions that these events of the 60's had their parallels in many other nations.  Thus, most of our explanations that point to American events of the 50's and early 60's - McCarthyism, Vietnam, GI Bill, whatever - could not have caused the cultural changes in Germany, Mexico, Japan, France.

My two pet theories - a younger generation with disposable income and color photography -  hold up pretty well under that examination.  They are not significantly strengthened, perhaps, but they remain standing while other theories crash and burn.  Disposable income is relative to economies, and even if the amounts aren't much (Mexico City,) they matter if the purchasing power is a significant fraction compared to the parents' generation.

There is a further parallel with the Great Depression.  Americans tend to speak of that even as if it were ours alone, and identify causes that are entirely internal: Smoot-Hawley, unrestrained speculation, shutting off immigration.  But those things had little effect on other countries, which point to their own internal events as the cause of their respective Great Depressions.

I've know that both of these phenomena were global, but I keep forgetting it.  What was your pet theory, and how well did it hold up to your plotting it against international events?


Monday, December 03, 2012

Fashionable Politics


I mentioned a few times during the election that it is more fashionable to be a Democrat, and this has its effect.  I have been saying similar things for years, and it draws ire.  I can see why.  I mean it to sting, thanks.  But it is only fair to say exactly what I mean by that.  If I am to give offense, at least let it be for the right reasons.
The central argument is three points:
1. In every society, some ideas, people, or associations are more fashionable than others.

2. Some people give their support on that basis and no other. That is, whatever they say, the fashionableness accounts for all the variance.

3. Democrats, including Obama, are currently net beneficiaries of this.

I don’t see that any of these three can be seriously questioned.  However, I quite consciously used the qualifier net beneficiaries in that third one.  It doesn’t all flow in one direction.  There are many American subcultures, and in some it is more fashionable to be Republican.  In many evangelical circles, you have to be prepared to justify an Obama bumpersticker.

It is in fact the third premise that causes all the controversy. First, “Fashionable” is a clear pejorative, which I do not turn away from.  Second, I suspect that there are those on the left who are quite certain that fashionableness flows away from them, not toward, and are prepared to give evidence. Third, with so many unmeasurables, it would seem that at a minimum, I should not be so sure of myself.  Point three will be hard to prove with any reliable numbers, yes?

Yet I am sure of myself.

For openers, everyone needs to return to the first two premises: there is fashion in politics, and for some people, that is enough.  Can anyone mount a serious argument against that?

My first contention is that liberals consistently pretend that no such thing as 1 & 2 occurred in the last election, or indeed, has been going on for some time. Yet when you put it out there as a general premise, they reluctantly, suspiciously have to acknowledge that of course that is what human nature is like.  My second contention is that by acknowledging this, the argument is over, and only the mopping up remains.  The mopping up will be lengthy, however, and will take at least two more posts.  For now, conservatives can feel smug – that will change by the end – and liberals can seethe.  That may or may not change.

Babe

Whenever I read John-Adrian's FB exchanges with his new GF, I think of this song.

That's not a good thing.



I had both "Look At Us" and "Sonny and Cher And Friends," somehow, though I wasn't an especial fan.  I think after buying the one for $3.77 (at Manchester Music on Lowell St, across from the famous Red Arrow Diner), I may have been given the latter as a present.

Norwegian Law

Over Thanksgiving, Chris told me that the Norwegian police routinely beat up people they arrest, if they get any lip.  The courts officially ignore this and the newspapers don't bother to mention it.  They used to beat up drunk drivers, but now that they take away their licenses immediately - sometimes forever - they no longer bother.

I thought Chris had misplaced a decimal point, but researching the usual fines, it is true that for going about 13 mph over the speed limit, he has a fine of $1400.  Also, he seems to have been lucky to have received the less stringent set of penalties, though his speed 65kph in a 40kph zone - deserved more.  The next ticket up includes a mandatory 18 days in jail.

Norwegians have about the lowest speed limits in Europe.  They allow guns and hunting, but every bit of ammunition must be accounted for or you lose the privilege.  They think Americans are gangsters, shooting each other all the time.  I suppose we have ourselves to blame for that, because the movies and other media we like ourselves, and the rest of the world seems to like to watch also, does suggest that most of America is essentially Detroit.

They also have gypsies moving in more and more, and my Romanian-born son becomes positively shrill when he describes how they dismiss his warnings about this.  How the official position of ethnic tolerance will square with the cultural preference for community order is anyone's guess.  But the problems and solutions will show up in Oslo before Tromso.

Europeans do tend to ignore the violent crime rate in Lyon, Malmo, Glasgow, Manchester, or the Paris banlieue (without me even getting around to mentioning southern and Eastern Europe).  Because the homicide rates aren't as high as American, they are quite self-congratulatory.  But rape, assault, drug trafficking, forced prostitution, pedophilia - these aren't good either.  The cultures are different.

Saturday, December 01, 2012

Jonathan Haidt


I have been encouraging people to read Haidt for a half-dozen years, not with unqualified approval, but because he is clearly onto something.  Now he is big news, with a NYTimes bestseller and a gig with TED. One is supposed to be gratified when the general public catches on to something one has recommended, and feel a warm I-told-you-so glow.  I don’t, whether because my character is too large for that or too small.  I’m merely annoyed at having to repeat myself.

First, Haidt is an honest man, or at least was when I first read about him.  His data about moral reasoning took him someplace unexpected – somewhere that looked right from the outset to go against his preferences – and he reported it fairly and followed the trail.  Good on him for that.  I don’t know if the criticism and fame have caused him to back down from that integrity, because I haven’t read The Righteous Mind. I am hoping he has stood firm. 

He has also modified his views in response to fair criticism.  I wish it were more, but I’m grateful for any.  His original research showed that moral reasoning is different in different groups. I noted at the time that the UPenn students were considered to have gotten the answers “right,” which struck me as an immediate red flag.  Something more akin to “thinks like a social psychology professor,” or even “knows how to answer test questions” was being measured, not moral reasoning.  Haidt didn’t see that at first, but caught on pretty quickly.  He has since attempted to refine and categorise the differences. Most controversially, liberals apply two axes to moral reasoning, conservatives apply five (now six).  This lead to irate liberals insisting that the other 3-4 axes were stupid and unnecessary, while conservatives glowered that this proved what they had been saying about the moral blindness of liberals all along.

At the time, I noticed immediately that liberals also reasoned along those additional axes, but it hadn’t shown up in the test because of Haidt’s originally liberal bias. (There’s a lot less of that now.) For example, one question was whether you would use an American flag to clean a toilet if you had nothing else.  The original “right” answer was Yes, because you were smart enough to see that the cloth was only symbolic, yadda yadda.  The Ivy League 20-year-olds got that right.  But Haidt hadn’t asked similar questions which might evoke the same response from liberals, such as whether you would wipe your bum with a newspaper photo of MLK or Gandhi if you had nothing else.  There were examples from the other axes as well, illustrating that liberals – and in fact all human beings – used all categories. I spent about three months pointing that out in comment sections around the web, and like to think I did my little bit in getting Haidt to come ‘round on that.

It does remain true that all groups do not apply all six axes with the same intensity, and some are indeed unimportant to one group or another. It also remains true that some, though not all, liberals view Haidt as the Antichrist.  They are unable to even remain polite in discussing his ideas.  He is becoming one of those figures that others dash themselves against, drawing amazingly stupid statements out of supposedly smart people. 
Alert readers will note that this general idea is precisely what CS Lewis wrote in The Abolition Of Man in the 1940’s.  We have similar moral precepts and groundings, but we rank them differently.  It would be interesting to know what Lewis would have thought of Haidt’s schema, which he concludes is as much biological as cultural.

Jonathan Haidt’s other repeated theme is that our moral reasoning, like all our thinking, is not under the strict control we like to think.  We decide something and then rationalize it immediately, as quick as thought. We’re fine with that idea when it applies to other people, but we rebel against it when it comes to our own group, and ourselves especially.  Those other knuckleheads might be voting for Romney/Obama for purely emotional, tribal reasons, but we – or at least a far greater percentage of Us – have solid logical reasons in voting for Obama/Romney. 

Anyone who has worked with addicts, or other categories which sap the insight, knows this.  The intelligent simply play chess against themselves, finding more elaborate reasons why they drink. It is not Haidt’s opinion, but it is mine, that liberals are especially prone to this type of self-delusion, not in spite of their gifts of intellect but because of them.  The gifts of summarizing, general knowledge, and social knowledge leave one especially prone to overconfidence in opinion. 

We’ve got a leg up here.  We discussed this at length for months in 2011, in the May We BelieveOur Thoughts?  series. This isn’t new information here. That our brains telegraph what we will decide before we ourselves have realized it, and the interesting neurological experiments illustrating this, we have noted before. (Brief summary for new readers: a helluva lot of our thinking is involuntary and not fully rational.  But not all.  People seek advice, people change their minds, people really are undecided and attempt to apply reason. Okay, well… some people do, and the others are at least theoretically capable.  Be humble, but not discouraged.) 

**     **    **

For all that, I have some criticism of Haidt’s theories.  Though he is clearly onto something which is holding up under repeated testing and examination, he may not be describing it accurately.  There is no particular shame in that.  It’s not that I have seen a better theory, or have one of my own.  But this is new territory, trying to discern where the tectonic plates are underneath our moral reasoning. I have raised enough red flags about his original theories.  Let me raise more.

Haidt is a researcher in social psychology.  In that field he may indeed be regarded as an authority.  He might make mistakes, and may even turn out to be wrong, but his errors are constrained there.  There are pitfalls he has entire awareness of which nonspecialists could easily miss. In describing the research in neurology, decision-making, imaging, and other branches of social science, is is one step removed.  He is much better placed to understand and describe than most of the rest of us, but these are allied fields, not specialties, for him. This removal grows greater as he gets away from his expertise.  His knowledge of genetics and evolutionary psychology is secondhand.  In particular, he seems to be positioning himself as an expert in moral philosophy, because he has a theory in social psychology which has bearing there.  In The Happiness Hypothesis this was quite clear.  He is a smart man.  He has some honesty, integrity, and open-mindedness.  He is willing to buck conventional wisdom.  He has thought about these things a good deal more than most people, and likely conferred with others about same. But in moral philosophy, he’s just another smart guy who has thought about stuff. 

The difficulty is likely to come when the variance between groups shows any genetic cause at all.  Haidt is going no further at the moment than asserting that all human beings have these categories embedded in our inherited schema, less cultural than heritable.  It's the standard mythology that evolution is reliable science up until about 50,000 years ago - just enough to kick fundamentalists with - and then pretty much stopped. Further differences are not allowed.  We have to be one big happy family after that. But the Steven Pinker questions, about the diminution of violence beginning in NW Europe, are going to occur to Haidt and allied researchers soon.  Do some groups have "better" moral reasoning?  What do we mean by that?  Can they be ranked? Oops.  No, no they can't.  Move along now.

I would think that the best line of escape is along epigenetic lines - that's very cool now.  But Pinker only partly relied on that.  He is smarter than I, as Haidt likely is as well, and if the ignore/mumble platitudes/wave the arms vaguely about the Enlightenment strategy worked for him, Jonathan my dart there as well.  Yet both are still young, and I have hopes they will push the envelope more.

Christmas Trees

I finally figured it out.  I think.

We have long shopped at cut-your-own-tree places, for the dual reason of family adventure and tradition when the boys were young, and because we put ours up very late (I would go later still), and the cut trees in the lots are picked over at that point.

Most of the trees at cut-your-own are quite dense, with little room to put ornaments which depend from branches rather than drape the exterior.  They are for those people who have ribbon, garland, lights, and some theme of ornaments, all on the outside.  Owls are big this year, I gather.  They are trees for beauty, and more purely decorative.

Our ornaments do not have a theme, unless "family history" counts. Odd, even unattractive ornaments have been acquired over the years, made as children's crafts or given by friends and relatives.  A few are carried over from our own childhood.  More ornaments have stories than I am interested in at this point.  My wife cares more, and remembers.

I couldn't understand why so many people who just have to be similar to us, because here they are on the same tree farm mailing list, getting up early on the first available day to traipse all over fields in Weare to compare trees, could all be the sort of persons who bought those other trees with hardly any room for ornaments.  Not until this year, just an hour ago, did I piece together that this is where one shops for boutique trees if one is going to do that Martha Stewart sort of tree.  The cut trees on the lots all have space for ornaments.  Those are family trees, like ours.  We are the unusual ones at the boutique tree place.

Thursday, November 29, 2012

Faith

"Did we really go to Grand Canyon?" I asked Emily.  "Did we really fly two thousand miles and see all the uncles and all stay together in the same house just a few days ago, and see llamas?" She smiled and nodded, thinking it was some joke or game. And so it must seem to a five-year-old.  Of course we did those things.  Of course I remember.

I'm mostly certain we did, but not quite.  I spend most of my life in a very few places, you see, but I read about and imagine many others.  Very rapidly, the quality of remembered reality and imagined reality is much the same.  A good portion of my knowledge that one is real and one not is how I have labeled it in memory.  Only secondarily do the qualities which distinguish actual events - the unpredictable, rather random additions to the story, the reassurance that others saw the same things - enter in.

I am a nostalgic person, as you know, and review old events in my daydreaming time.  I don't think I have added any whole items to reality that were merely invented (though I'll wager I have added many details), but I do sometimes question the real memories.  Did I really live there? Did I actually have a class with that girl?  Was that really I who reached into the water?  It all seems unlikely now, as if it happened to another person. There is no longer any verification, just electrochemical flittings in my brain.


Or also, I have had the experience of looking at a common word and wondering if it is spelled correctly. Our.  Strange-looking word.  Is that really the word or is there some other spelling that will suddenly look more real to me?

One of the arguments against the Christian faith, even among those who are trying to make solid, logical, arguments, is that it all looks very implausible.  At least, that is how I read the complaint.  The New Atheists try to disguise that, and a hundred others tip their hand without realising, but to me it just leaps off their pages.  The theistic description, whether creationist or not, just seems so odd to people that it simply doesn't square with their experience.  The existence of evil sometimes comes into play here.  To a great many folks, it just seems that in the face of that much unlikeliness, theists of any sort would have to mount quite compelling arguments to overcome it. It looks less than 1% likely to be true.

Well duh.  Every possible explanation looks less than 1% likely to be true.  Existence is a jarring, puzzling thing.  Falling back on "Things Are," isn't any better than "I Am." Hawking seems quite pleased that he has pushed the question of existence back another step - that universes can be preceded by other universes instead of by nothingness. But nothing has changed. Ah, we found that Sunday doesn't have to be the first day of the week.  There's a Saturday before it. Well, yes, and I am not at all discomfited to imagine there might be a Friday, or even - gasp - a Thursday!

I shouldn't sneer, because folks lose their faith over such things, which is tragic.  If you focus on how unlikely it is that I ever hitch-hiked in South Carolina - I'm sorry, I mean that something vaguely like the Christian God exists, you can get quite caught up in that. It can all look impossible in a flash.  In their discouragement, people who go through that often don't notice that their new belief, only vaguely adopted and not much thought through, is just as unlikely, or more.  There's no way out.  It is easier to just avoid thinking very hard, and believing just a little of everything.

When one is feeling buoyant and optimistic, all currently-held beliefs remain intact.  When depressed, all beliefs come up for question, as changing one might give relief.  This is why both conversions and de-conversions are more frequent at such times.  You may accuse that such conversions are thus suspect.  This I gladly grant, if we will drink the whole cup and note that de-conversions are thus suspect as well. Not to mention all the adopting or non-adopting of other beliefs, popular among our set or no.

Christians don't do themselves any favors in this realm when they try to insist they've got some rock-solid proof that others should attend to.  I've found nearly all such claims tip the balance a percentage point or two and are worth considering.  That's all. Similarly, the criticisms of belief which seem so solid and enormous to the nonbelievers or doubters do indeed tip the balance in my mind back a point or two the other way.  Just not any more than that, because dropping one belief always entails picking up another, and I like to have a look at that before I peel it and eat it.

Amongst the entire array of possible explanations of how you came to be sitting here, furrowing your brow, none looks the least bit likely. Yet each of us has a metaphysic we live by, whether we have thought it through and acknowledged it or not. I am of the belief that if we start from a neutral spot, the Christian explanation slowly noses the others out - not necessarily in a flash, though our understanding may cascade rapidly when we attend to the question rather than evading it.

I take it from what I read of both faith and doubt in the world that I am not very typical in this approach.  But it may help someone out there.

Wednesday, November 28, 2012

We No Longer Need A Hall Of Fame

The steroid and Hall of Fame discussion was happening on sports radio tonight. I'm not sure the various sides put their arguments all that well.  One group would say that when we really, in our hearts, know someone was juiced, like a Barry Bonds, we should not consider them for such a high honor.  Another faction would say that such knowledge is along a continuum, not an either-or, and we have no way of reflecting that in our eligibility requirements. Actually they wouldn't say that, but they should, as it's clearer.

So why have a Hall of Fame at all, then?  Why not close the membership as it stands, not as a protest, but as an expression of a particular era.  One of the main reasons the Hall was founded was to preserve the memory of great ballplayers, so that later fans will have some idea of what came before, and what the historical context is for baseball events now.  (From the very beginning it has gotten many things,wrong, BTW, enshrining players who were merely above-average and neglecting highly-deserving candidates who played in more obscurity.)

That context is no longer needed.  Historical information about baseball is now enormously available, and literally thousands of people make comparisons across eras for general discussion.  In the 1930's and 40's, not only did not know about players in other eras unless they were on their home team (or one from New York), they could not easily even get that information. That has been true until quite recently, actually.

We no longer need a baseball Hall of Fame, except as a repository of records and symbolic gathering place. It can become the Hall of History now. The "honor" of nomination and election doesn't carry the weight it once did.

Church and Mental Illness

Retriever sent along an article from NAMI Faithnet on gently confronting those in church who do not understand mental illness.

We had a series for adult studies at my church twenty years ago, which I co-taught with two others.  Perhaps we should do that again.  I recommend group-teaching that one, because the misconceptions are so common, and often held rather defiantly, as if they are part of the Faith As Received.  Having others beside you helps keep you from getting defensive.

Monday, November 26, 2012

Poll

Inspired by Bethany's discussion of a Pew poll about male and female attitudes toward marriage over at Bad Data, Bad!

I have discussed inappropriate polling and deceptive polling before.

Who Can Post

I have tried something to see if I can lose the spam and still let people comment without word verification.  It may prevent anonymous comments.  Could folks test and see if they can comment, especially if you would ordinarily be anonymous here?

Email wymanhome at comcast if you cannot.

Sunday, November 25, 2012

Grand Canyon - A Review

It's big.

Why Persuade?

Some discouragement after seeing Barney Frank on a CNN show at the airport this morning, plus some commentary on Jonathan Haidt when I got home. Well, those were just some of the tent pegs of a vast pavilion - no, I lied, it's a small lean-to - of thought. When people are challenged or criticised (ideas or behavior), they default immediately to the thought of what they didn't do wrong, and are irritated that you had the nerve to mention anything else.

That's not other people, that's is I.  It's just that it only irritates me when it's other people.  I'm defensive and default to my better qualities because that's my right.  The rest of you still need work.

I will write about this some.

Train Song



I didn't come back back by train, but this fits.

My sympathies for those who have to travel much to earn their daily bread was much in my mind today.  Sponge-Headed Scienceman has a lot o' that.  With one thing and another, it took about 27 hours to get home from Williams, AZ.  Not much sleep, and I am reminded again of the discomfort of sitting for long periods.

BTW, I had never heard an early live version of this song, and was surprised at the added 7ths in the chord progression.

Saturday, November 17, 2012

Blog Change

Tigerhawk is starting a new blog The Spirit of Enterprise, and letting the old one go.  He explains here.   It is a topic I know less about, and have less interest in, though Sponge and Dubbahdee, at least, might be fans.

I doubt I will put the new on e on my sidebar, nor delete the old one just yet, letting it drift to the bottom instead, in case it's a false alarm.  It usually takes a long period of inactivity before I delete someone.  Good marketing would decree that I always have crisp, fresh, active blogs there, but I'm not wired that way.

Train Song

Probably the last of this series, as I will actually be taking the train from Houston to Tucson come Monday.


Curiosity

Remembering the war discussions over the last decade reminded me of the few times I have heard or read someone noting the number of American war dead approaching, becoming equal to, and then exceeding the number killed on 9/11 - as if this was a marker for some sort of evenness, or completion, or a turning point.

I always feign that I have never heard of this counting before and asking, rather innocently, what they think is being balanced.  Actually, sometimes just silence can make folks play back in their heads what they just said out loud, and re-evaluate whether it makes any sense.  Most people do pick up that there really isn't anything sensible being measured in that equation, and sign off with something lame.

I don't think they necessarily meant any harm, but it is the kind of vague thinking that drives me nuts.  There's a Bad Thing, and it has a number associated with it, like 3,000 deaths.  Therefore, when something related to the Bad Thing is being discussed, and a number of deaths associated with that starts to get near 3,000, the mind automatically ties those two things together, as if some puzzle has been solved, or some stasis has been reached.  It is likely one of those useful shortcuts the brain has developed in remembering things and understanding them.

No problem there.  But why let the thought come out of your mouth?

On The Possible Utility of Recent Wars - Part IV

You might intuit that the end of my last comment to terri may suggest that I think the nation-building part of our recent wars was in error. Your intuition would be partly correct.  I am far less convinced that was wise.  The Colin Powell advice "If you break it, you own it," sounded like the only kind and decent way to go at the time.  George Bush's thought that if we just bring freedom to people they will gradually do better and the world will be a better place looks less solid now.  Why do we own it if we break it? We eventually found a bunch of B and C-grade stuff for making WMD.  Nothing A-grade, but no big deal.  Break the other stuff, which Hussein was also not supposed to have, and go home.  If we have to repeat again in 10 years, or in two other countries as well, fine.

Not a very realistic plan, however, as Americans wouldn't stand for it.  We feel obligated to build schools, hospitals, and highways to give them a leg up.  Minimising the collateral damage, and paying handsomely for what damage we do just doesn't seem like enough to us.  We want to fix "root causes."  Except the root cause is petty tribalism even within the major groupings, and to fix that they have to stop marrying their cousins.  (See also, Hatfields, McCoys, and extreme clannishness leading to blood feuds.) That could take awhile.

Not to say that it is useless, or never happens, or does no good.  I think it does.  I think bringing democracy and cooperation to places, insisting, however temporarily, that they behave better and educate their daughters, remains a good thing.  Just not as good as promised, and looking like it will take much longer than expected.

I was one of the ones who already had low expectations, remember.  I said all along that we didn't have to turn Iraq into Switzerland, but Brazil 1970 would be fine.  I am now hoping that Brazil 1870 can be sustained in Iraq, and wonder if there is any lasting change in Afghanistan at all. Hell, there's little change in Kosovo, and they're in Europe.

The paleocons said this all along.  They may have painted things too darkly, that there is no hope of any change, but their predictions weren't far off.  Cultures change slowly, and only when there is pressure to do so, not mere good intentions.  Conservatives tried to hush John McCain when he said 25 years, knowing that it would sound bad, but even John may have been too optimistic, eh? At a minimum, nationbuilding costs a lot more than we expected.