Friday, November 16, 2012

On The Possible Utility Of Recent Wars - Part III


I will next argue, as I have a few times before, that our natural human understanding of the narrative of history biases us toward the belief that the world would be pretty much the same if we changed one thing, except for that one thing.  We may not hold that as a theory – we may even say the opposite is more likely and the chaos of events very unpredictable.  But we were not attacked, except some small incidents we got control of, so we tend to think that is pretty much how events would have unfolded.  It is a natural blindness, because we have no story to fasten on that shows us what the attacks would be.  How can you remember what didn’t happen?  What did happen once takes on an enormous impression of inevitability that isn’t real.

I argued with my brother that worse things might have happened in the Middle East.  He was aghast, thought what I was saying was insane denial.  How could it be worse? Two expensive wars, American soldiers dead, countries hating us. 

I don’t laugh at his POV, I think I understand it and feel it pretty strongly myself.  But I also think it is a dangerous illusion that must be fought against, not an indicator of reality.  This is the Middle East, after all, where amazingly bad things can get even worse quickly.  That each possible scenario we can imagine is unlikely in itself does not mean that in aggregate, worse things couldn’t have happened.

Let me pause here to acknowledge that they might have been bad things that we chose to have nothing to do with, or bad things that could be more easily solved by bombing the crap out of a particular capital or port and calling it a day, or any number of other cheaper, possibly better solutions.  This is in no way a positive argument that either war was the best idea – only an argument that the consensus complaint is not persuasive; and that some action which seriously discouraged an escalating trend of violence against us had to be enacted.  War does that pretty well.  Even badly fought, not-really-worth-it wars can do that.

On The Possible Utility Of Recent Wars - Part II


That I might comment at all on international violence and deterrence is in one sense laughable.  There are people who devote their lives to this study, and the list of things they know which I don’t is enormous.  We all know, in our own fields of knowledge, how incredibly stupid a blowhard sounds, making pronouncements that we are tired of pushing back year after year.

Yet that is not the whole story.  Entire fields of knowledge are upended by marginal character, or even complete outsiders, all the time.  Most outsiders are fools, not worth listening to.  But “expert” attitudes self-reinforce and eventually become less useful.  Sometimes they become quite useless and actually stupid.  There are many possible reasons for this, which we have touched on before but will not here.  But why it happens is not so important at the moment as that it happens, and I will cite some evidences that I can at least take a shot at explaining international events.

  1. I have seen it happen in fields that I know something about, right before my eyes.  Freudians and ego psychologists (many of whom misread Freud) were in their last ascendancy when I started in this field.  They now have to scramble to show that even any of their theories and treatments hold, with any diagnoses (some do, with some diagnoses), and they are laughed out of the room in discussing autism, schizophrenia, and other clearly physical conditions.  Along the way I have watched lots of therapies, backed by people with superb credentials, be revealed as useless fads.  In baseball, the stats guys have changed the way everyone evaluates players, including the guys who have contempt for stats guys.  Linguists tried to laugh off Greenberg and the other lumpers and connecters, but the geneticists are now giving solid evidence for three, rather than three hundred, Amerind groups, and no one even grudges him his African categories now.
  2. Those experts don’t agree with each other, not even close, and an outsider can see institutional leanings that an insider is blind to.  Ben’s friend at State knows acres more than I do about internecine rivalries in Indonesia – and he’s still young.  But he’s at State, which disagrees with the CIA, which disagrees with military intelligence, which disagrees with their respective counterparts in the UK or Australia, which disagrees with the think tanks and the academics in a dozen related fields and the group violence researchers.  In my most cynical moments, I believe that all of these are simply enacting their original prejudices in more and more complicated fashion.

So I have not only a citizen’s right to speak, but potentially, an intellectual right as well.

Perceived weakness gets attacked.  Do not take what people say are their reasons as their reasons.  Al Jazeera is still saying the embassies were attacked because of the movie. Groups point to historical events, recent or remote, as the source of their resentments and their reasons for violence.  They are quite convinced that these are their reasons, and they convince the people around them – say, for example, business contacts, State Dept officials, and visiting academics – that these are their real motivations.  I think they are wrong.  Resentments fester for centuries with little open hostility, and very minor resentments can activate violence – when there is vulnerability.
But surely, the Japanese didn’t attack Pearl Harbor because they thought America weak? Yes, they did, if you look at the specialised sense of weakness and the attack.  They thought America entering the war on her own terms and on equal footing was a problem.  But they knew many Americans did not want to go to war, and strongly suspected that military assets in a few locations were vulnerable.  Destroying those before America could get a fully-formed emotional readiness for war might discourage us enough to say.  Don’t bother.  Make the best deal we can, we’ll trade with them as we go, accepting their dominance in the Pacific.  We can still do business. That’s not an idea that we were weak in terms of their ability to invade San Diego, but weak in terms of a single objective of enormous value to them.  The Japanese certainly didn’t have any set of resentments against us, other than in the narcissistic sense of believing that Pacific dominance was their natural right which we interfered with.  Similarly, Al Qaeda did not think America weak in terms of being ripe to invasion of Washington and giving over the keys to the next Caliph, but in terms of not wanting to mess with extremist Islam around the world.  They wished to make it expensive enough to discourage us. They spoke often about waiting us out and winning through greater resolve.

Germany didn’t have especial resentment against Belgians and Norwegians, nor the Huns against Europeans.  It may be axiomatic in postcolonial thinking that it is resentment against the West that drives violence, but the areas in question are plenty violent with each other when we’re not there.  I used to give a fair amount of resigned credence to blaming the British for desert boundaries or Americans for trading with rich South Americans.  I now pretty solidly reject that as excuses – rationalizations.

Resentments aren’t irrelevant, but they aren’t the primary cause we tend to think they are.  The more knowledge we acquire, the more we tend to believe that these resentments are the key, and America eliminating them the key.  We fall into this trap naturally.  It goes with the territory of interacting with people.  What is the evidence that it is reliably true?  Do nations that we give stuff to like us better?  Not reliably.  With individuals, it is often the case that the more you give them, the more they resent you.  Nations…yeah, pretty much.

Next, the idea that the inconclusiveness of a war is an argument against it is not strong.  Very few wars are conclusive.  Even those which seem so at the time have ways of lingering.  In general, a war is not conclusive unless one side is absolutely demoralised and must surrender on any terms.  This is not always so.  Some conflicts just do gradually wither because people get other lives and priorities.  Let’s look at American history: the American Revolution bled on through impressment of sailors through the War of 1812, a late extension of the original war. WWII is now quite commonly seen as a continuation of an unresolved WWI. Vietnam was conclusive in our losing mostly because we didn’t want an inconclusive war, because we thought that impossible.  Compared to what?  The Mexican War?  Indian wars? Korea? WWII looks nice and conclusive because it was conclusive with our enemies, the Axis Powers, but our Russian ally made Eastern Europe an inconclusive mess for 45 more years. 

We may not like it, but inconclusive is what wars usually are.  Yet they often do solve things, like slavery, or genocide.

On The Possible Utility Of Recent Wars - Part I


It is my preference to make a more general positive case, so I will only answer terri’s and Dave’s objections briefly.  I hope to suggest lines of refutation, rather than fully argue the points.  As a consequence, you may feel I have not fully heard what you are saying.  Likely so.  But I’m not answering all I heard.

I am not sure how far we can push the equivalence of America and small nations compared to the police and individuals, but there is at least some similarity, so let’s go with it, recognising that it is incomplete. The drawing of a firearm in a confrontation is not the only force response.  When the police surround a place, that they are armed is implied.  When they turn on the blue lights and use techniques to control the situation that people find intimidating, or when they patrol an area to increase their presence, all imply force and possible violence if necessary.  I don’t see that as irresponsible saber-rattling.  Just so with nations.  There are implied force actions or statements that a president might use that his critics might call saber-rattling that I would call wise warning and diplomacy. David’s viewpoint isn’t insane- it is close to the Colin Powell doctrine and Teddy Roosevelt’s, both of whom knew many things I don’t (more on the weaknesses of experts later) – but I still think it is wrong. Abjuring force until it is clearly necessary and then using it fully is a respectable strategy, but I don’t think it is the best, and it certainly isn’t the only. Other strategies might be implemented badly and make things worse, but abuse is not use, and saber-rattling can prevent violence as well.  Show of strength does not always provoke.

There is a growing idea in Western society that because soft answers sometimes turn away wrath, that they are a relatively dependable method of doing so.  I think confirmation bias is very powerful here.  Where I work there are those who believe various soft techniques almost always work better with clients and thus they avoid confrontation.  This is good, generally.  But there are cases where it does not – like our guy in the news this morning - not only as an unfortunate exception, but as a general rule with certain types of clients.

Terri’s second idea I also partly subscribe to – that in response to violence by jet, we make violence by jet more difficult, and continue to improve our techniques in that. Improved surveillance and spy-stuff?  Love it.  Cheap at any price.  Partial solutions, steadily improved, are great – and they are often far less expensive than war to boot.  But England had violence by subway, Spain violence on the trains, boats attacked, lots of places had cars with explosives. What are essentially law-enforcement techniques are indeed our first choice way to go.  But I’m not sure there is agreement that we have gotten that much bang for the buck with Homeland Security.  Response measures are sometimes not distinguishable from shutting the barn door after the horse is gone.  The highlight point, which I will expand in my positive case, it that there were no attacks of any type until recently, because a primary cause was reduced. Going to war with heavy focus on particular networks of enemies has worked to convince them to choose other targets, or none.  We dissuaded people from acting as enemies.

I am not one to make too much of individual incidents as indictments of a particular president’s actions, BTW.  Violent, evil, insane people are by nature not fully predictable.  That Bad Event 227 happened on a president’s watch may or may not be significant.  People make political mileage out of that, but I am more cautious.  Trends matter, not one-offs.

Thursday, November 15, 2012

Captcha

Saturday I will be turning on the Captcha function while I am away.  The amount of comment spam I am receiving was already large and has now doubled.  I don't want to have to delete 1000 spam comments when I return from our Thanksgiving trip.  Sorry for the inconvenience - you will all just have to work a little harder.

Ouch

This morning's radio comment was that Rick Reilly is stealing his humor from old "Please Don't Eat The Daisies" episodes.

That should leave a mark, but it won't.  He'll still be sure he's right and everyone else just doesn't get it.

Temporary (I Hope) Incoherency

There are suddenly many questions at once, and I am not seeing my way to clarity.  Once comments multiply on a post I tend to move it up to the main stage and do a new post.  Or perhaps, as the ruler of my domain, I just want to give my own comments visibility.

The original post that got us rolling was about insult, offense, and fairness. Terri had mentioned some public conservatives who are insulting as examples that the triumphalism of liberals, though unseemly, was not worthy of especial disapproval.  I am no longer familiar with much public commentary, I'm afraid.  Still, I think those leopards may not change their spots that easily, so I will venture comment.

When Limbaugh first came out, I found his style shocking but his arguments reasonable.  He would make an outrageous generalisation, often mocking, but back it up with at least something - a string of quotes by prominent feminists who said much the same as he was claiming, though in words that sounded more acceptable, for example.  Or recordings from the previous evening's news and commentary in which multiple supposedly neutral sources used the same unusual phrasing, which could then be traced back to a DNC press release earlier in the day.  I was impressed. Granted, he was reporting selectively, but he had real stuff to report.

I compared him at the time to political cartoonists, who were, and are, far more unfair.  At a minimum, they don't take calls from opposing viewpoints. they don't have to answer any criticism, in fact.  Why, I asked, were liberals so outraged when it was their ox being gored?  I still think that argument has merit.  Limbaugh changed the game, and brought the political cartooning style to talk radio.  Television comedy had long been allowed that level of unfairness, but it wasn't purporting to be news.  One could see intimations of that on SNL, and before that on Smothers Brothers and Laugh-In with pretend news, but on radio that line was unbreached. Limbaugh also did that briefly in a TV format, with the trappings of news broadcasts, yet making fun of his opposition.  It was considered infuriating and unfair.

Now it is standard.  That is what Stewart and Colbert do, though their comic style and politics are different.  Liberal talk radio has not worked well (last I heard, though Rachel Maddow seems to have persisted), but the premise of having a one-sided, take-n-prisoners political humor show is now established.

Let's look at that shock from the other side.  Even many liberals were stunned when Bill Clinton made fun of sectors of the American people while running for president.  They wondered if there would be backlash.  A few earlier figures like Tip O'Neill had done some of it, and there were certainly suspicions that many presidential candidates had contempt for one or another group of Americans, but you just didn't say that. A president is supposed to represent all Americans, and not ever attack his own.  Reagan would say "our liberal friends" with a little bite and it drew howls of rage - and I tended to agree.  It seemed to me to be technically within the rules but using tones of voice to communicate something different. Adlai Stevenson's campaign was insulting about groups of Americans, but I don't believe he ever was directly. Then Clinton blew that out of the water completely, with he and Hillary openly mocking the culture they were running against.

This continues to the present, with Al Gore talking about the double XX chromosome or Taliban wing Republicans, or Obama talking about people bitterly clinging to guns and religion.  Conservatives just can't get over that a president or potential president just isn't supposed to say that.  Worse things are said by others all the time, arousing less anger.  Something about the context makes it shocking. (Historical note:  Roosevelt did it often in his first two terms but stopped thereafter, so far as I can tell.  Perhaps that emotional content was part of the fury that he was a "traitor to his class.")

There's a host of sociology research to do, and experiments that could be run here.  Do conservatives and liberals, or men and women, or Greatest Generation and Millennials, or black people and white people, have very different context expectations of where and how criticism should be said?

I have become increasingly sympathetic to this idea of context and giving offense, as, for example, my discussion about Peyton Place in Some Rambling About The Printed Word about 10 days ago. There really is a difference between talking about sex in one medium versus another, and I think political offense shows the same pattern.  I was objecting after the election to some offensive, angry comments in what I had expected to be a more social, respectful context.  There were a score of offensive bumper stickers in the parking lot I just shrugged at - that's an expected context. Links from conservative sites to outrageous comments at expected liberal sites I didn't even click through.  I expect HuffPo to be like that.  But newsier sites, even in the Op-Eds, are supposed to hold themselves to higher standards.  Insults can be implied, criticism harsh and even somewhat unfair, but the outpouring of venom is supposed to be kept inside certain bounds.

Wow.  I didn't even get to militarism, saber-rattling, and shows of force.  Perhaps tomorrow.

Wednesday, November 14, 2012

Train Song

Disagreement

Good to have terri's disagreement.  She is polite enough that I don't get irritable and shouting, and her thought is different enough from mine that it causes me to clarify for myself exactly what I mean and what I think.

I have a very good friend who expressed similar sentiments about militarism, the lack of benefit of the recent wars, and the high cost.  I have heard more than one conservative starting to come to that conclusion.  The paleoconservatives and more libertarian types already leaned that way.  There may be some consensus forming about this.

I see the appeal, but I think they are wrong.  No, I think they are possibly right, but probably wrong.  I think saber-rattling can be a good thing.  I think we can point to benefit.  I think we can point to some reasons why the cost was necessary.  As the pendulum swings, I think I should make the arguments I can, anyway. I will start with one point to ponder; a different starting point than we usually work from now, but one that was common then. 

Had we continued as before, the most likely result would be that we were attacked again. Repeatedly.

Stay tuned.

Tuesday, November 13, 2012

Coalition Politics

I have had a lot of focus over the course of my blogging career, on an American group that is largely cultural, perhaps even ideological: the Arts & Humanities tribe. Let me give a quick summary of that before I try and shoot this film from a different angle. The Arts & Humanities tribe is largely white, liberal, educated word-people. They might be miseducated, but not uneducated. They are something close to the first of Snow's Two Cultures (now Three, with the social sciences). They heart NPR. They weren't all literature or anthropology majors, are not exclusively white, nor are they always liberals. The writers at Maggie's Farm or National Review, for example are certainly A&H, but not liberal. Yet on the whole, they tend that way. Boundaries are fluid depending on how intense an identification, or how much actual scholarship rather than posing one requires for membership, so estimates are suspect. But let us say they constitute 7-17% of the populace. They are disproportionately represented in running things, especially government. Lawyers (some), librarians, writers, psychologists, academics of many stripes. Very Canadian border, as they are concentrated across the top of the country: New England, Upper Midwest, Pacific Northwest.

 My people. That's who I come from. I'm rather suspicious of them and in rebellion against them in these later decades, but culturally, these are who I am most comfortable talking to.

When we look at all those "Romney Won White Voters" graphs and articles, keep in mind that those numbers were in spite of this sizable group of A&H tribe. Subtract them out, and ponder.

hbd* chick linked to a set of graphs by The Audacious Epigone which shows the electoral vote breakdown if we counted variously by income, sex, or race. For example, if only white men vote, Romney wins 490-41 (7 undecided).

Coupling that with similar data that Steve Sailer extracted from the Reuters-IPSOS poll, where we learn that married Jewish women voted for Obama 66-34, we have an entirely different way of looking at the culture, at least in terms of voting.

 Let us assume, arguendo, that this second method is much better than mine; that a far more simple tribalism of race, religion, gender, etc, is true. Who we will tend to vote for, and what appeals by candidates we will respond to, are largely a result of accidents of birth, with all the worrisome implications that we can be manipulated with increasing accuracy by campaign teams with each passing year.

If that is true, then the demographics are going to go so consistently against the Republicans that they will not ever win more than an occasional narrow majority in House, Senate, or Electoral College. They will never be able to bend their message enough to peel off enough stragglers from all the other groups.

The Democrats are not a unified party, but a coalition. Have been for a few decades now. Black voters are not the natural cultural allies of union members or Jews, but they can agree to defeat Republicans and then each get something of what they like in the next year's legislation.
Therefore, what the Republicans need not a broadened message, but a coalition partner. A group that can sign on despite differences in exchange for cabinet positions, or the introduction of particularly dear legislation. There is something of this already. Social conservatives, economic conservatives, and libertarians overlap, but are not the same thing. They are a proto-coalition.

What coalition partner can they hope to attract with consistency, whether ethnic, ideological, or cultural?

Monday, November 12, 2012

Seeking Moral Superiority

There are stories that come around - they have a parable feel to them even though they are seldom biblical - of merciful kings.  It is considered a good thing for a king to be merciful; historians note this with approval.  There was a poor man who owed a great deal of money which he could not pay.  His creditors wanted to take his house (or put him in jail, or sell off his fingers one-by-one or whatever; the usual creditor stuff).  They brought him before the king.  The king noted that he had a wife and small, cute children (or maybe had some disease, or had taken many beatings as a child or whatever; the usual sympathetic victim stuff). He forgave the debt and sent the man home, causing poets to praise him for his mercy.  What a guy, our king, eh?  We try to overlook the fact that he just gave away someone else's money, because - well, because we painted them as evil so that the story would feel right. We feel morally superior for having approved this message.

We respond to these things powerfully.  I feel bad for this poor fictitious man and beaming in approval of the king even as I make fun of it.  The fact that some people just got robbed - well, it serves them right for being evil villains who don't care about the poor, doesn't it?

It turns ugly, however, if it turns out that the poor man is a member of the king's clan and the creditors are from a rival clan. In a quick about-face, we recognise that this is a tawdry story of corruption, nepotism, and power politics.  The despised creditors now become honest businessmen who can't get justice in the courts, left shaking their heads as they walk away.  And what about their wives and children, after all?

*            *           *           *            *

In our politics and social values, we like to feel morally superior to our opponents.  Also, we prefer that superiority to come cheaply. Liberals pointed out that "Support The Troops" bumper stickers and wearing flag pins were cheap substitutes for patriotism, and were enraged they had become popular. No, enraged isn't an exaggeration.  One can't read True Patriot without noticing how much the authors hate their opponents. (If folks are interested in that topic in more depth, I covered it around the time of the last election.  Quick Hitters; If You Give A Liberal A Cookie; Modesty, Humility, Understatement; Political Faux Pas.)

Yet they have a decent point.  There is a hint of claiming the high moral ground at low cost with the whole stickers and pins thing. I don't doubt there are plenty of people who just wanted to make a statement of what good patriotic people they are - implication that you might not be - and so gravitate to the visible displays. But I see at least three weaknesses in making that accusation:
1. The idea that it is the armed forces making the real sacrifices comes up pretty regularly among the stickers-and-pins crowd.  They deflect a lot of the moral credit to others.
2. Just because you take on some inexpensive gestures doesn't mean you aren't willing to pony up for the expensive ones as well. People who gave limbs might also wear flag pins, right?  Any implication to the contrary is a little insulting. And revealing.
3. Interpreting the stickers and pins as a sneaky form of supporting the president is so far beyond reality that it is good evidence of projection.  Always hearing dog whistles and people talking in code is pretty good evidence that you believe that's how the world works.

We do not usually choose our tribe because it is more moral.  Rather, we think our tribe more moral and go looking for ways to prove that.  It is cart and horse. What we think of as the issues has a lot of by-product about it.  Sentence first, then trial. 

I bring all this up because I think the shoe has been on the other foot these last elections.  I am likely over-influenced by my uncle's correspondence and my brother's FB posts again, and the sample of liberals who write for money or comment on sites is going to tend toward the True Believer.  And yet...I expect the time leading up to an election to be laden with posturing, and I try to apply discounts as I can.  We are all at our worst.  There are those in my own tribe who seem mere posers and partisans. I am not above this myself.

Yet the anger continues to spew after the elections. Romney et al did not lose because of some faulty technique or bad timing or bad strategy, but because the American people recognise that he and the Republicans are hatemongers.  They lie, and we won, and that proves it.  They hate women.  They hate immigrants, and the legal vs illegal distinction is just a pose. The don't care about the environment. (For example, he Kevin Drum editorial that Sailer linked.)  I note again the importance of social approval in liberal thinking.

(For the record, I don't know what the tone has been in the other parts of the Democratic coalition, the investment bankers, the government unions, the African-Americans, the soft-hearted.  They may not be spewing.)

All mind reading again.  In light of Jonathan Haidt's research that liberals actually don't understand conservative moral reasoning as well as they are themselves understood, it seems ironic that the belief that they understand us should extend to mind-reading.  Perhaps the irony is inevitable.  If you can't follow someone's reasoning, yet you are sure they are evil because they are from the other tribe, then you kinda have to mind-read.  The most revealing stat: one poll had Obama winning under "cares about people like me" 81-18.  I think that number is likely inflated, but still revealing.  We have an electorate that is concerned whether the president cares about their sort of people.  Or more exactly, gives the impression that he cares, because who pretends to know, really?  That's getting into Father Stalin territory, isn't it?  I doubt we'll ever ever go too many steps down that road, but the point is we shouldn't be going any steps down that road at all.

Sunday, November 11, 2012

Milestone

Tomorrow afternoon sometime, Assistant Village Idiot will hit a quarter-million pageviews all time. It sounds like a lot, though I'm not sure it is - rather like figuring out that you've driven a half-million miles lifetime. The number seems padded, somehow. Still, it's nice to see a round number go by.

I keep thinking I must be approaching a stopping point, and then I don't.  The 4000-post total might come up early 2013, if I still have things that attract me to write about.  I had a few topics I wanted to comment on in depth when I started.  Those days are long gone.

Thank you very much.

Barzun on Revolution

Jacques Barzun, in From Dawn To Decadence, 2000, discussing what happens to the intellectual life of a country in revolution (defined as a violent transfer of power, whether quickly or slowly)
A curious leveling takes place: the common people learn words and ideas hitherto not familiar and not interesting and discuss them like intellectuals, while other people neglect their usual concerns art, philosophy, scholarship - because there is only one compelling topic, the revolutionary Idea.
I think not only of the American Revolution or the Protestant Reformation when I read that, but smaller examples as well. This happens in any great change, violent or not, though it may be less pronounced.

Saturday, November 10, 2012

Asylum Suitcases

Dubbahdee sent along an article about a cache of suitcases from the 1910's-60's found abandoned in an attic at an asylum for the insane in NY.  When patients died, the staff had not destroyed the limited personal belongings, but kept them stored away against a day of relatives claiming them. (The Collector's Weekly general site it wa found on is interesting in itself.)

Some findings are poignant, some puzzling, many quite predictable.  The 1960's predate my direct experience of state hospitals (though I did tour one in 1968), but when I started at NHH in 1978, there were many patients and staff who had been there for years, and many of the objects around dated from that time.  The photos had a familiarity.

It put me in mind of the James Thurber short story The Night The Bed Fell - the era, and all that talk about attics, and Thurber's dementing grandfather is a somewhat loose connection, but I think you can follow it.  The story was a favorite in our family, and I read it aloud to the boys several times.

You might wonder why I bring up putting eccentric grandfathers away, or into attics at all as I myself age, but I am safe for the present.  Our particular attic can only be reached with great difficulty, and through a small opening. I do keep a wary eye out at times, and have sudden reasons to worry more about being set out on an ice floe.

As a final, full-circle irony, the link to the story is school based, and has a quiz following.  But the quiz is for another Thurber short "The Man and The Unicorn" by mistake.  And the second story is entirely appropriate to where this whole discussion started.


Wednesday, November 07, 2012

Best In His Field

We have a new patient in his late 20's.  He thinks there is an emblem on his brother's head telling him to kill him, and believes words are coming out of his own neck that others can hear.  Thought broadcasting.  Schizophrenia.  Pretty straightforward, actually.  The job of the hospital at this point is assessment of danger and function, connecting him with services and benefits, seeing what antipsychotic might work, etc.

He had psychological testing 2-3 months ago at The Grand Psychiatric Hospital, the famous, Ivy-affiliated one in the 617 area code.  The one that historically looks down on the others, including us many times in my direct experience.  So we sent for said testing, which turned out to be four paragraphs of rather pedestrian Rorschach interpretation. Nothing more - no WAIS, no PAI, not even an MMPI, House-Tree-Person, TAT, nuttin'.  I did have to talk to the testing psychologist in order to get the fax number for the release of information and give her our fax.  The PhD wanted to engage in conversation that the testing clearly showed the patient had schizophrenia.  She had referred him on to Dr. Mufson, who she thought was the best psychiatrist in Boston and the only one she referred to.  And shazaam! Dr. Mufson had also thought that the patient was definitely schizophrenic.  We should call Dr. Mufson, she thought, to discuss this.  She spelled his name, gave me the address, email, phone, and fax.  She listed his affiliations, how she knew him, and why she thought so highly of him. She kept coming back to this, as if trying to extract a promise from me that we would call him.

Dr. Mufson thought he should eventually be on clozapine, she said.  That's the other name for Clozaril, she reminded me.  Well, fine.  That "eventually" tells me that Dr, Mufson noticed that he had improved but been undertreated on risperidone, and had a non-trial of Geodon because no one told him or his mother to take it with food, unfailingly, or it doesn't work.  Thanks ma'am.  I'll make a note of it.

I'm sure he's just fine and all that, but we didn't bother to call him.  It is analogous to bringing your kid to the ER, the nurse and the MD both thinking his leg is broken, taking an X-Ray and seeing that it is broken, and them asking you to wait for treatment.  Because tomorrow, tomorrow Binky, the best orthopedic guy in all the Northeast will be in, and he will look at the films.  Which he will look at and say "This kid has a broken leg.  What the hell do you need me for?"

Bethany over at Bad Data, Bad described a similar scene, in which the patient had traveled past many quite decent hospitals to get some standard medical care at a top-flight hospital's ED.  But it's not just a patient problem.  It's a provider problem as well.

BTW, this is part of why I am not excited by either having Obamacare or not having it.  I have a bias against such large federal interventions because citizens pressure politicians to pass them at great cost, thinking that somehow these sorts of problems will fade into the background forever.  But they don't.  Human beings do dumb stuff, and they don't stop just because someone passes a law that says things will be better now.  OTOH, I don't have a free market faith that says these things will be minimised if we just let the natural ebb and flow of success and failure operate on its own.

Both solutions are insane.  Got that? Mankind is fallen and both solutions are insane.  We do things to try and make treatment better, and generally, we have succeeded, gradually and painfully in improving medical care.  Long may it wave.  But if even PhD's can be counted on to say stupid things, what hope have the rest of us to consistently avoid it?

Moderate Republicans

The next time you get a sneering email or comment from someone about how Republicans were just too far-right, close-minded, anti-abortion and religious and that's why they lost, remember these three words: Bass, Brown, and Tisei.  

Tuesday, November 06, 2012

Rolling Stone

A coworker, a 41-year old mother of two with 18 years' sobriety, mentioned that she has a subscription to "Rolling Stone." That struck me as slightly but not ridiculously odd, so I looked up its demographics. On a lead-in page, I found the view of themselves they want to put out to potential advertisers.
Rolling Stone goes beyond just taking the pulse of youth culture.
Rolling Stone is the pulse of youth culture.
| |
Whether the subject is music, TV, movies or politics—over 12 million young Americans trust and turn to Rolling Stone every two weeks to keep them up on the subjects they care about most. Bold stories. Big interviews. Insightful commentary. All delivered with energy, passion, irreverence and a point of view that defines its audience.
Then I read the demographics of its readers.
I suppose if life expectancy is going to continue to rise, then having half of your readership over 35 can be considered "youth" culture, but it seems a stretch to this child born in 1953. Perhaps a portion of those older subscribers are buying it to put out in their waiting rooms. The only times I hear about RS is if they've just done some Top 1,000 Lost 45's of All Time, or are footnoted for some political piece heavy on assumptions and short on wondering if there is another possible POV.

They do seem to get actual modern artists on the cover, though. They're not crazy. They know all their readers, even the 11.4% that are 55+, want that.

I'm also wondering about that "other" category for race. There just aren't that many mixed-race people in America, unless they all subscribe to RS somehow. In a conservative publication, that would be "white people who are trying to screw with your data because they hate balkanizing Americans by race." But I don't think that's going to hold for Jann Wenner's crew. I'm guessing it's more like "white people who consider themselves minorities in spirit."

Though one should never rule out, for all ambiguous answers from any group,
that a considerable percentage may be "people who didn't understand the
question," or more succinctly: "Whoa. Dude."

1984

A paranoid patient of ours had taken the book 1984 out of the patient library.  His particular paranoia is very much concerned with thought reading and thought broadcasting. He is not a person one might expect to have good general knowledge of literature and political culture, and he did not have much preconceived notion what it might be about.  He had heard somewhere it was an important book.  We were a little concerned what he might take away from the book, but we don't get much involved in people's selections. 

He found it sad.  This guy had a girlfriend, but he lost her.

He didn't really notice the paranoia-inducing parts of the book.  Those were just normal background to him.

Monday, November 05, 2012

Extra Ramble

The "Printed Word" post was inspired in part by looking at people's FB pages with political content.  I know, it's Facebook, it's not supposed to be lengthy or nuanced.  But these are intelligent people, who have entry after entry of snarky criticism of candidates they don't like and self-righteous posturing about how they really, really care about this issue, all expressed in the most oversimplified, highschoolish words, but very clever visuals. Therefore, the posters at least must think the statements effective.  Therefore, this patent idiocy must be being carried by the clever visuals and condescending tone.  Therefore, those elements are more dangerous in hacking into people's political views and more dangerous to the republic.

Except I'm not sure that's actually true.

Still, it's distressing to watch intelligent people descend to sloganeering and sneers, seemingly unable to think clearly anymore.  Is this who we all, in fact, are - with only a thin rind of intellect covering?