Tuesday, June 30, 2015

Quora

Someone at work asked if Quora is a reliable source of information.  I gave an incomplete answer off-the-cuff, and am writing one out here.  Perhaps I will email her the link.

It's a simple, democratic concept, relying on collective knowledge and crowd wisdom.  People propose questions, however many others as want to answer them, and the rest vote on what is the best answer.  You can dig down to see what the 2nd or 10th-place answers are, if you wish. It does not rely on argument or discussion. For what it is, it's great. Best in class.

But it illustrates beautifully how all forms of communication have strengths and weaknesses. The quora community is not a random sample of humanity, or even of online humanity.  It is self-selected, and bias effects tend to increase rather than decrease over time in such communities. I suppose it could be partially hijacked, with selected topics being put forward by some nefarious group which acted in concert to vote certain answers up. It would take effort, and the effect would likely narrow.

Here is what I see as biases from my own observation.  I welcome other data.

It is a tech-heavy group, with lots of questions and up-votes about computer culture and operation, current science questions about desalinisation or black holes or medicine.  Therefore, one can predict the type of answer that will be voted best when the question is some relative of "Is technology really good for us, or is it going to kill us?" The top answer will note that there are risks and unintended effects of all new technology, but holy-moly, look where we've come, technology is gonna save us! It will be a really good answer of that type, thoughtful and well-written, but its overall conclusion is foregone.

It won't necessarily be the best answer, but it will be a good one, and the one this group thinks is best.

It is largely white North American, white northern European, and Northeast Asian in its audience. You will find a lot of Americans asking about China, voting up answers by 1st-generation Chinese-Americans. You won't see many questions or answers by African-Americans, Hispanics, Native Americans, North Africans, or Central Asians. Also, please note, you will not find the Chinese asking many questions about Japan, or Koreans about India. The curiosity doesn't extend there.

There are a lot of young people, with a lot of focus on "How do I get a great job in Silicon Valley?" "What's the best way to make a lot of money fast?" "What is the meaning of life, really?" This group also has the usual outsize fascination with rogues, eccentrics, and Guinness Record-type info: "Who was the smartest person ever?" It's geek trivia night there.

It is generally liberal, especially socially liberal, so if a general question comes up that seems to ask "Is America a good thing in general or are we all screwed up?" the answer which receives the most votes will be of the form "Insofar as we have done and will do liberal stuff, we've been great.  But there's too much exploitation, self-congratulation, and other countries do some things better than us." It won't contain any lies, though it may omit some key facts, such as winning the Cold War.  It will be the best mid-liberal answer, which is a good thing to read.

OTOH, there is a fair bit of fascination with military topics, and not just cyberwar. There aren't many parenting questions, but there are quite a few about education and training.

20 comments:

james said...

And if one were to ask whether Hobbes or Epictetus were right about freedom?

Assistant Village Idiot said...

There would be enough people to get a few answers and a decent vote-getter, I imagine. I can't predict the bias, though I have a bias what I think the bias would be.

Texan99 said...

I have sometimes, to my frustration, visited an answer.com-sort of site when I was trying to find the answer to some fairly straightforward question about how things work. The answers there tend to be pretty horrible. The answers at Quora at least are fairly thoughtful and intelligent, and are more likely to lead me to a useful link or concept, though I agree with you about the bias. I followed it for a few days and then lost interest.

I also made the mistake of buying the book that everyone on Quora said was the best ever. I couldn't finish it. Something about modes of thought. Really banal.

james said...

For technical questions in a wide variety of areas, there's Stackoverflow. Have a look at the dropdown menu on the upper left...

Riko JR said...

I can only express a word of thanks, nothing else. Because with the content on this blog I can add knowledge Thank you very much has been sharing this information. Do not forget to visit our website to share information and knowledge about health.
cara mengobati pengap
cara mengobati tbc pada anak

QnC Jelly Gamat said...


I can only express a word of thanks, nothing else. Because with the content on this blog I can add knowledge Thank you very much has been sharing this information. Do not forget to visit our website to share information and knowledge about health.
obat syaraf terjepit
cara mengobati sakit kepala

QnC Jelly Gamat said...

I can only express a word of thanks, nothing else. Because with the content on this blog I can add knowledge Thank you very much has been sharing this information. Do not forget to visit our website to share information and knowledge about health.
ahlinya obat herbal keloid
obat herbal unggulan
ahlinya pengobatan tipes
qnc jelly gamat
obat luka bakar herbal
obat kista epidermal

QnC Jelly Gamat said...

I can only express a word of thanks, nothing else. Because with the content on this blog I can add knowledge Thank you very much has been sharing this information. Do not forget to visit our website to share information and knowledge about health.
obat pityriasis alba paling ampuh
cara mengobati sakit pinggang

QnC Jelly Gamat said...


I can only express a word of thanks, nothing else. Because with the content on this blog I can add knowledge Thank you very much has been sharing this information. Do not forget to visit our website to share information and knowledge about health.
apotik qnc jelly gamat pangandaran
gudang agen resmi QnC Jelly Gamat

Unknown said...

Adana Seo
Adana Web Tasarimi
Adana Temizlik Firmasi
Antalya Hali Yikama
Antalya Hali Yikama
Adana Hali Yikama

Unknown said...

Protez Tirnak
Toner Dolumu
Magaza Poşeti
Baskili Poşet
Hali Poşeti

Unknown said...

موديلات مكائن غسيل السجاد
أسعار مكائن غسيل السجاد المستعملة
مكنة غسل السجاد قائمة الاسعار
ارخص مكنة لغسل السجاد
مكائن تنظيف السجاد ذو النوع الصناعي
موديلات مكائن غسيل السجاد

Unknown said...

I can only express a word of thanks. Because with the content on this blog I can add knowledge I, thank has been sharing this information. Do not forget to visit our website to share information and knowledge about health.
cara mengobati penyumabatan pembuluh darah
obat nyeri lutut akibat asam urat
cara menyembuhkan penyakit gudik






I can only express a word of thanks. Because with the content on this blog I can add knowledge I, thank has been sharing this information. Do not forget to visit our website to share information and knowledge about health.
obat kliyengan alami
cara pemesanan QnC Jelly Gamat
obat kliyengan alami







I can only express a word of thanks. Because with the content on this blog I can add knowledge I, thank has been sharing this information. Do not forget to visit our website to share information and knowledge about health.
cara mengobati penipisan lapisan otak
cara mengobati selulit
obat infeksi usus

Axe Moria said...

I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post.
obat jantung bengkak
cara menyembuhkan maag
obat radang lambung

Riko JR said...

thank you information, very helpful, do not forget to visit also kunju our page to berai information about health
cara menghilangkan budug
obat penyakit varikorel
obat hidrokel di apotik
obat penyakit lichen planus

JESSICA JANE said...

If you have a history of illness that is difficult to recover, maybe our next article will help you to recover

Walatra Gamat Emas Kapsul
Cara Mengobati Penyakit Rubella
Cara Mengobati kapalan pada kaki
Cara Mengatasi Rematik
Cara menghilangkan kista ateroma
3 Cara Alami Atasi Keputihan

4477satu said...

Pengobatan Kemaluan Mengeluarkan Nanah Gejala khas gonore termasuk keluarnya cairan dari vagina atau penis tanpa disengaja, nyeri saat buang air kecil, dan pada wanita disertai perdarahan sewaktu-waktu. Obat herbal penyakit gonore yang pertama adalah obat yang terbuat dari tanaman kumis kucing. Tanaman ini sangat mudah dijumpai di berbagai wilayah di Indonesia karena tanaman ini merupakan tanaman obat yang dapat mengatasi berbagai penyakit termasuk penyakit gonore. Tanaman kumis kucing merupakan jenis tanaman yang memiliki batang tegak. http://syphillissd.com/2018/07/27/menyembuhkan-kemaluan-mengeluarkan-nanah/

Herbal Penyakit Kanker Serviks Yang Mujarab Kanker serviks adalah penyakit kanker yang terjadi pada daerah leher rahim. Yaitu obat kanker serviks herbaldaerah pada organ reproduksi wanita yang merupakan pintu masuk ke arah rahim. Letaknya antara rahim (uterus) dengan liang senggama wanita (vagina). Kanker ini 99,7% disebabkan oleh human papilloma virus (HPV) onkogenik, yang menyerang leher rahim. Berawal terjadi pada leher rahim, apabila telah memasuki tahap lanjut, kanker ini bisa menyebar ke organ-organ lain di seluruh tubuh penderita. Badan Kesehatan Dunia (WHO) mengatakan, saat ini penyakit kanker serviks menempati peringkat teratas di antara berbagai jenis kanker yang menyebabkan kematian pada perempuan di dunia. Di Indonesia, setiap tahun terdeteksi lebih dari 15.000 kasus kanker serviks. Sekitar 8000 kasus di antaranya berakhir dengan kematian. Menurut WHO, Indonesia merupakan negara dengan jumlah penderita kanker serviks yang tertinggi di dunia. Mengapa bisa begitu berbahaya? Pasalnya, kanker serviks muncul seperti musuh dalam selimut. Sulit sekali dideteksi hingga penyakit telah mencapai stadium lanjut. Mencegah Penyakit Kanker Serviks

Obat Ambeien Yang Aman Untuk Bumil Wasir bisa hilang dengan perubahan gaya hidup yang sederhana. Tinja yang keras bisa memperburuk pembengkakan dan untuk menghindari hal ini semakin buruk, maka perubahan sederhana dalam diet anda dapat membantu melunakkan kotoran anda. Diet tinggi serat membantu mencegah sembelit, membuat tinja lebih lunak dan lebih mudah untuk dikeluarkan. Sayuran, buah-buahan dan biji-bijian adalah sumber serat yang baik. Hal penting lainya adalah mengkonsumsi banyak air, minimal delapan gelas air setiap hari. Selain itu, menjaga fisik untuk selalu aktif juga dapat mencegah sembelit dan mengejan saat buang air besar. Dari hal itu maka dikatakan bahwa perubahan gaya hidup adalah salah satu cara yang efektif untuk menangani wasir. Obat Kapsul Ambeien Yang Aman Untuk Ibu Hamil

Riko JR said...

Hopefully, sustenance will be easy and simplified in all matters
Solusi Pengobatan Alami
obat babak gatal selangkangan
Cara Mengobati Tinnitus
obat chikungunya di Apotik
Cara Mengatasi Penyakit Gudik

Siti Solihah said...

This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing websites that understand the value of providing a quality resource for free. It is the old what goes around comes around

routine

risa herbal
penyebab sakit pinggang
obat mata glaukoma
obat gagal ginjal
obat penebalan dinding rahim
obat penghancur kanker
obat varikokel

Unknown said...

I can only express a word of thanks. Because with the content on this blog I can add knowledge I, thank has been sharing this information. Do not forget to visit our website to share information and knowledge about health.
cara mengatasi radang panggul
obat infeksi saluran kemih
obat herbal infeksi usus
sapnudin herbal
obat pusing kliyengan
nama obat diare pada anak